Property value checks: TEAC voids assessments if Hacienda does not justify the review first
In two rulings of 8 October 2026, the TEAC (Spain's central tax appeals board) annulled assessments where the tax authority checked the declared value without first explaining why it doubted it, even when the check was carried out within a tax inspection.
Published on · News· 7 min read· English version of our Spanish story

The story in 30 seconds
Spain's Tribunal Económico-Administrativo Central (TEAC, the central tax appeals board), in rulings 2825/2025 and 4338/2025 of 8 October 2026, requires the tax authority to explain, before checking the value of an asset, why it does not accept the declared value, including within an inspection. If it does not, the assessment is annulled and the file goes back. This matters to anyone with an assessment for a higher value who can still appeal.
Key points
- The TEAC requires the tax authority to explain, before checking a value, what circumstance, fact or indication makes it doubt the declared value.
- The requirement also applies to value checks carried out within a tax inspection (rulings RG 2825/2025 and RG 4338/2025 of 8 October 2026).
- Without those prior reasons, the assessment is annulled and the proceedings return to the point at which the value check was notified.
- The criterion applies the Supreme Court judgment of 19 November 2025 (cassation appeal 113/2024).
- You have one month from the day after notification to appeal the assessment (articles 223 and 235 of the Ley General Tributaria, Spain's General Tax Act).
Key dates
Supreme Court judgment
The Supreme Court (cassation appeal 113/2024) requires the tax authority to justify, before checking a value, why the check is necessary.
TEAC change of position
Ruling RG 207/2025, on a gift taxed under inheritance and gift tax, annuls the assessment and orders the case sent back where those prior reasons are missing.
TEAC rulings on inspections
Rulings RG 2825/2025 and RG 4338/2025 extend the requirement to value checks carried out within a tax inspection.
Deadline to appeal the assessment
One month from the day after notification, by recurso de reposición or reclamación económico-administrativa. A tasación pericial contradictoria can be requested within the deadline for the first appeal or claim.
What has the TEAC decided on value checks?
On 8 October 2026 the Tribunal Económico-Administrativo Central (TEAC, Spain's central tax appeals board) issued two rulings (RG 2825/2025 and RG 4338/2025), classified as doctrine in its DYCTEA database. Both apply the Supreme Court judgment of 19 November 2025 (cassation appeal 113/2024), which requires the tax authority to justify, before checking a value, why it is necessary to do so.
What is new is that the TEAC extends this requirement to value checks carried out within a tax inspection (article 141.d of the Ley General Tributaria, Spain's General Tax Act). According to the TEAC, failing to give those reasons beforehand is not a mere formal defect without consequences: the assessment must be annulled and the proceedings sent back to the moment the value check was notified, so that the missing reasons for opening it can be remedied.
The TEAC classifies these rulings as doctrine. Doctrine that the TEAC lays down repeatedly binds the regional tax appeals boards and the tax authorities of the State and of the autonomous communities (article 239.8 of the Ley General Tributaria).
What changes compared with before?
Relying on a Supreme Court judgment of 23 January 2023, a failure to justify the opening of a value check used to be treated as a formal irregularity that did not invalidate the assessment; the regional tax appeals board of the Illes Balears, for example, applied it that way. After the judgment of 19 November 2025, the TEAC changed its position in a ruling of 23 February 2026 (RG 207/2025) on a gift taxed under the Impuesto sobre Sucesiones y Donaciones (inheritance and gift tax) and repeated it on 28 April 2026 (RG 8883/2024) on an inheritance.
In ruling 4338/2025, the Balearic regional tax agency had checked, within an inspection, the value of a property bought in December 2018. The TEAC notes that the inspection record merely reproduced the legislation and set out the result, without identifying any circumstance, fact or indication that could call the declared value into question. It adds that reasons must be given whatever the way the procedure is opened and whatever valuation method is used.
Who does this doctrine affect?
It affects anyone who has received an assessment for a higher value than the one declared after a value check, for example when buying a resale property (Impuesto sobre Transmisiones Patrimoniales, ITP, property transfer tax) or when inheriting or receiving a gift (inheritance and gift tax, whose article 18 refers to the valuation methods of the Ley General Tributaria). The TEAC has applied it to both taxes: the rulings of 8 October 2026 concern ITP, and those of 23 February and 28 April 2026, inheritance and gift tax.
Since Ley 11/2021 of 9 July, the tax authority cannot check the value of a property when the taxable base is its Catastro reference value (valor de referencia) or a higher amount (article 46.1 of the consolidated ITP Act and article 18.1 of the Inheritance and Gift Tax Act). Value checks still apply to properties without a reference value or whose value the Catastro cannot certify, to other assets and rights, and to earlier transactions still under review, such as the 2018 purchase in the Balearic case.
If what you dispute is the reference value itself, the route is different: it is challenged when appealing the assessment or when requesting the correction of the self-assessment (article 10.3 of the consolidated ITP Act).
What should I do if I have received an assessment for a higher value?
Check the notice that opened the value check. If it only cites the legislation and the resulting value, without explaining what specific circumstance led the authority to doubt the declared value, you can rely on this doctrine in a recurso de reposición (appeal for reconsideration) or a reclamación económico-administrativa (claim before the tax appeals board) against the assessment. The deadline is one month from the day after notification (articles 223 and 235 of the Ley General Tributaria).
Within the deadline for the first appeal or claim you can also request a tasación pericial contradictoria (an independent counter-valuation) to correct the value (article 135 of the Ley General Tributaria). If you already have an appeal or claim under way, check whether the lack of prior reasons has been raised.
Annulment does not always mean paying nothing. The TEAC sends the case back to the point at which the value check was notified so that the authority can give reasons, which means it can repeat the check properly. In its ruling of 28 April 2026 (RG 8883/2024), as a first assessment had already been annulled earlier, the TEAC ruled out a further referral back and a third assessment.
Managora
How we help you challenge a value check
If you have been notified of an assessment for a higher value than the one you declared, we review the file and check whether the opening notice explained why your value was doubted. We agree a written quote with you before starting and prepare the recurso de reposición or the claim before the tax appeals board, using the arguments of this TEAC doctrine.
If the figure itself should also be disputed, we request the tasación pericial contradictoria within the deadline. You sign the mandate from your phone and we file the documents on your behalf with the Agencia Tributaria (the Spanish tax agency) or your autonomous community's tax office, all remotely. For your specific case, message us on WhatsApp from this page.
We file it for you
Fixed price before you start, signature from your phone and filing with the authority.
- Reclamación económico-administrativa (tax tribunal claim) (TEAC / TEAR / local TEA)We draft your reclamación económico-administrativa against tax assessments, tax penalties, refusals to refund, refusals of deferrals, enforcement o...€500Start this procedure →
- Tasación pericial contradictoria (independent expert valuation challenge) (LGT art. 135 plus RD 1065/2007)We draft the application to correct the valuation made by the tax authorities using your own expert and, if the two experts disagree, a third exper...€250Start this procedure →
- Recurso de reposición ante la AEAT (LGT 222-225) (administrative appeal before the Spanish Tax Agency)We draft the optional recurso de reposición (administrative appeal) against acts of the Agencia Tributaria (Spanish Tax Agency): tax assessments, t...€350Start this procedure →
Your case, with the law firm
If your situation has nuances, a registered lawyer studies the whole case and gives you a fixed quote.
Cases like yours, explained by the firm
To understand it in depth
- Challenging the Cadastral Reference Value and Expert AppraisalHow to challenge a reference value inflating your ITP or ISD tax: rectification with refund, appeals, evidence and contradictory expert appraisal (2026).
- Appealing to Hacienda: TEAR/TEAC, rectification and binding rulingsHow to appeal to Hacienda without going to court: TEAR/TEAC claims (free, no lawyer), rectifying your tax return and binding rulings from the DGT.
Frequently asked questions
Can the Spanish tax authority check the value of a property without explaining why?
No. Under the Supreme Court judgment of 19 November 2025 and the TEAC's doctrine, the tax authority must justify, before checking a value, why the check is necessary, identifying some circumstance, fact or indication that casts doubt on the declared value. If it does not, the resulting assessment is annulled, including when the check was carried out within a tax inspection.
If the assessment is annulled for lack of reasons, do I no longer have to pay?
Not necessarily. The TEAC sends the proceedings back to the moment the value check was notified so that the authority can remedy the missing reasons, and it can then repeat the check. In its ruling of 28 April 2026 (RG 8883/2024), the TEAC ruled out a further referral back because a first assessment had already been annulled earlier.
How long do I have to appeal an assessment based on a value check?
One month from the day after notification of the assessment, both for a recurso de reposición (article 223 of the Ley General Tributaria) and for a reclamación económico-administrativa (article 235). Within the deadline for the first appeal or claim you can also request a tasación pericial contradictoria, an independent counter-valuation (article 135).
Does this doctrine help against the Catastro reference value?
It is a different situation. When a property's taxable base is its reference value or a higher amount, the tax authority cannot check its value (article 46.1 of the consolidated ITP Act). The reference value itself is challenged when appealing the assessment or when requesting the correction of the self-assessment (article 10.3 of the same Act).
Does it also apply to inheritances and gifts?
Yes. The TEAC has already applied it to inheritance and gift tax: its ruling of 23 February 2026 (RG 207/2025) concerns a gift and that of 28 April 2026 (RG 8883/2024) an inheritance. This tax uses the valuation methods of the Ley General Tributaria (article 18 of Ley 29/1987), except where a property is declared at its reference value or at a higher value.
Sources
This story is based on these publications, official ones first, checked on the day it was published.
- Criterio TEAC 00/04338/2025, de 8 de octubre de 2026 (DYCTEA) ↗ · Tribunal Económico-Administrativo Central, 8 October 2026
- Criterio TEAC 00/02825/2025, de 8 de octubre de 2026 (DYCTEA) ↗ · Tribunal Económico-Administrativo Central, 8 October 2026
- Criterio TEAC 00/00207/2025, de 23 de febrero de 2026: cambio de criterio, donación en el ISD (DYCTEA) ↗ · Tribunal Económico-Administrativo Central, 23 February 2026
- Ley 58/2003, General Tributaria, artículo 134: práctica de la comprobación de valores ↗ · Boletín Oficial del Estado
- El TEAC permite a los autónomos anular liquidaciones de Hacienda por sus inmuebles si falta este requisito ↗ · Autónomos y Emprendedor
Informational content written by Managora from the sources cited. It does not replace the original law, call or decision, which are the binding ones.



