Law firm guidesReal estate and conveyancing

The flat changed hands with community fees unpaid: who pays

Last updated 2026-11-10 · Reviewed by Jaime Piñeira Pardo, registered with the ICAM bar, no. 138826

The short answer

The owners' community claims through the monitorio (a fast-track payment procedure) under article 21 of the Horizontal Property Act before the civil section of the Tribunal de Instancia (the first-instance court): from the former owner, everything he failed to pay; from the new one, with the flat itself, what fell due in the year he acquired it and in the three preceding calendar years. Each instalment lapses after five years, and a settlement must first be attempted with each of them.

You chair the owners' community of a building with twenty flats. The owner of flat 2A stopped paying in 2020; the bank enforced its mortgage, was awarded the flat by a court decree in March 2025 and then sold it to a fund that has not registered its purchase: the land registry extract (nota simple) still shows the bank as owner. The flat is empty and the debt exceeds 9,000 euros. The company that manages the fund's properties replies that it only pays “the last three years”, the bank says the flat is no longer its business and nobody knows anything about the former owner. The building's property manager has only sent ordinary letters. You want to know whom each euro is claimed from, before which court, and how much has already been lost.

The case, in five lines

What is brought
A monitorio petition (a fast-track payment procedure) under article 21 of the Horizontal Property Act that joins the personal claim against whoever owned the flat when the instalments fell due with the claim based on the statutory charge on the property (afección real) of article 9.1(e) against the new owner, with the registered owner sued so that enforcement can proceed against the flat and, where applicable, the seller who did not notify the sale.
Before which court
The civil section of the Tribunal de Instancia (the first-instance court) for the debtor's domicile or, at the community's choice, the one for the place where the flat is located (article 813 of the Civil Procedure Act). If anyone opposes, the case continues before that same section as a juicio verbal (the shorter form of civil proceedings), whatever the amount (article 250.1.15).
Deadline
Each instalment lapses five years after it fell due (article 1966.3 of the Civil Code); the lapse period is interrupted by an out-of-court claim, by the debtor's acknowledgement (article 1973) and by the request to negotiate (article 7 of Organic Act 1/2025). The statutory charge is not a time limit but a perimeter: what fell due in the year of acquisition and in the three preceding calendar years, counted backwards from the date of acquisition. If the request to negotiate gets no reply within thirty calendar days, the petition must be filed within one year of its receipt.
Who can bring it
The claim is brought by the community, represented by its chair or, if the owners' meeting so resolves, by the professional secretary-manager. It is directed against whoever owned the flat when the instalments fell due, against the new owner for the amount the flat is charged with, against the seller who did not notify the sale for what accrued afterwards, and against the registered owner, where different from the real owner, solely so that enforcement can proceed against the flat. An heir who accepts is no ordinary acquirer: he answers for everything not yet time-barred.
Financial risk
If the debtor pays or does not appear, he bears the fees of the lawyer and of the procurador (court representative) for the initial petition, within the limits of article 394.3 of the Civil Procedure Act. If there is opposition, the general rules on costs apply, and a judgment entirely in the community's favour includes those fees even where their involvement was not mandatory. Asking the new owner for more years than the flat is charged with, or for a personal order for someone else's debts, loses that part and may carry costs; and whatever falls outside the window or becomes time-barred can only be recovered from the former owner, often insolvent by then.

Two different sources of payment: the one who did not pay and the flat that changed hands

Article 9.1(e) of the Horizontal Property Act separates two things that in practice get confused. The debt belongs to whoever owned the flat when each instalment fell due, and that person owes all of it, with all his assets, until it becomes time-barred. But the flat answers too: the acquirer, “even with title registered in the Land Registry”, answers with the property itself for what the previous owners owed, up to the limit of what is attributable to the part already due of the year in which he acquires and to the three preceding calendar years. The Act declares the flat legally charged with that payment.

Answering with the property is not the same as owing. The Tribunal Supremo (the Supreme Court) has held that the new owner answers with the flat acquired and not as a personal debtor, and that this charge only comes into play when ownership is transferred. The procedural consequence is concrete: the buyer is not asked to pay, but to submit to enforcement against the flat up to the amount charged. If he does not pay, the community may attach and auction that flat, but not his salary or his accounts for the previous owner's debts. What falls due from the day he acquires, on the other hand, is his own debt, and he answers for it like any other neighbour.

The window is counted backwards from the date of acquisition, not from the claim or from registration. If the flat was bought by deed on 15 June 2026, the property answers for the instalments that fell due between 1 January 2023 and that day; 2022 and earlier can only be claimed from the seller, and everything after 15 June is the buyer's own debt. In a court auction, the date taken is that of the decree awarding the flat. This is the calculation most often got wrong: counting from the claim or from registration demands years that are not owed and leaves out others that are.

The sale: the debt certificate and the seller who gave no notice

In the deed, the seller must declare that he is up to date or state what he owes, and produce a certificate of his debts to the community that matches his declaration; without it the deed cannot be executed, unless the buyer expressly releases him from it. The secretary issues it within a maximum of seven calendar days with the chair's approval, and both answer, where there is fault or negligence, for its accuracy and for the harm caused by any delay. Releasing the seller does not remove the charge on the flat: a buyer who forgoes the certificate buys, blind, the debt of the current year and of the three before.

A wrong certificate opens another front. If the community certified that nothing was owed and arrears then surface, the buyer has a serious defence: the certificate exists so that he knows what he is buying, and a good number of courts do not allow the community to go back on what it certified itself against someone who relied on it. The community is left with the seller, who is still the debtor, and with the liability of whoever signed the certificate with fault or negligence. That is why, when we act for the community, we check the certificate before it goes out; and when we act for the buyer, it is the first thing we ask for.

The seller must also notify the change of ownership to the secretary by a means that records its receipt. If he does not, he remains jointly and severally liable with the new owner for whatever accrues after the sale, with a right to recover it from him. What few people read is the next paragraph of article 9.1(i): that liability does not apply if any governing body of the community learned of the change by other means, through conclusive acts of the new owner (attending the owners' meeting, paying bills in his own name) or because the transfer was common knowledge. Before suing the seller, we review the minutes and the payment records.

Bank, Sareb or fund: from when they owe and whom to sue

While the flat is merely attached or in the middle of a mortgage enforcement, the bank owes the community nothing: the owner, and debtor, is still the neighbour, and he is the one to claim from now, without waiting for the enforcement to end. In that enforcement, moreover, the community's claim for the part already due of the current year and the three before is preferential and ranks ahead of the mortgage, because article 9.1(e) places it before the mortgage claims of article 1923 of the Civil Code. It is asserted through a tercería de mejor derecho (a third-party claim to be paid first), which is not admitted once the bank has been paid or has been awarded the flat; we explain it in our guide on attachment and auction.

With the award of the flat, a dation in payment or the purchase of the property, the bank, Sareb or the fund become acquirers like any other: they answer with the flat for the window counted from that date and, for everything afterwards, as debtors in their own right. A fund that bought the loan must be distinguished from one that bought the home: the former owns nothing until the flat is awarded. And what nobody warns you about: each new sale counts the window again from its own date. If the bank sells to the fund a year later, the oldest years drop out and can only be claimed from the former owner.

The land registry extract (nota simple) is the first piece, because banks and funds are slow to register and sometimes never do. Article 21.2 of the Horizontal Property Act allows the registered owner to be sued so that enforcement can proceed against the property registered in its name, and this is no minor option: article 20 of the Mortgage Act (Ley Hipotecaria) bars registration of the attachment if the registered owner is a person other than the one against whom the proceedings are brought, and article 38 then requires enforcement against the property to be stayed. The Tribunal Supremo has held that such a registered owner who is not the debtor cannot be ordered to pay: it only submits to enforcement.

An inheritance does not work like a purchase

When the flat passes to the children of a deceased neighbour, the three-year window does not protect the heirs. Article 661 of the Civil Code provides that heirs succeed the deceased in all his rights and obligations, and article 1003 adds that whoever accepts outright answers for the burdens of the estate not only with its assets but also with his own. The instalments the deceased left unpaid are a debt of the estate and are claimed in full, limited only by the lapse period of each one.

An heir who accepts with the benefit of inventory answers only up to the value of the estate's assets, flat included (article 1023). While nobody accepts, the claim is brought against the herencia yacente (the estate pending acceptance) and its possible heirs, and the instalments keep falling due. The community can force a decision: through the formal demand of article 1005, the person called to inherit has thirty calendar days to accept or renounce, and if he stays silent he is deemed to accept outright. If everyone renounces, the estate passes to the State, which always takes it with the benefit of inventory (article 957), or to the autonomous community whose civil law so provides. How to sue in each case is set out in our guide on the deceased neighbour in arrears.

The window matters again when the flat leaves the family. If the heirs sell it, the buyer answers with it for what fell due in the year of purchase and the three before, and the heirs still personally owe everything else not yet time-barred. That is why, for an inherited flat, the statement of debt always separates three blocks: what the deceased owed, which is a debt of the estate; what fell due after his death, owed by those who inherit or, while nobody accepts, by the estate pending acceptance; and, if there was a sale, the buyer's window, counted from the deed.

Five years per instalment and a window that narrows every month

Each instalment lapses separately five years after it fell due: article 1966.3 of the Civil Code applies that period to payments due yearly or at shorter intervals, and the Tribunal Supremo applies it to community charges. The lapse period is interrupted by a court claim, by an out-of-court claim and by any acknowledgement of the debt (article 1973), and also by the request to negotiate, from the moment the attempt to deliver it is recorded (article 7 of Organic Act 1/2025). An ordinary letter does not prove that it arrived: the claim that interrupts is the one that can be proved.

The charge is not a time limit, but nobody warns you that it narrows. The instalments within the window are old debts and lapse at their own pace: if the flat was bought in June 2026, the January 2023 instalment becomes time-barred in January 2028, and from then on every month without a claim loses another month of the window. Waiting for the bank to finish its mortgage enforcement has the same effect, because the window is counted from the award of the flat and the first years of arrears fall outside it. The only way not to depend on it is to get there first: an attachment registered in the Land Registry before the sale follows the flat for the full amount recorded.

Do not assume that claiming from one interrupts the period against all. Between the seller who did not notify the sale and the new owner there is joint and several liability by law for what accrues after the sale, and for those instalments interruption against one reaches the other (article 1974 of the Civil Code); but the buyer is not a co-debtor of the old instalments, he is the owner of a flat charged with them, and the claim is sent to him too. In Catalonia the rules change: article 553-5 of its Civil Code extends the charge to the part already due of the current year and the four years before, and article 121-21 of the same Code cuts the lapse period for periodic payments to three years.

The monitorio against several parties: what the community must have done first

Before going to court, the owners' meeting approves the statement of the debt, and it is best to approve it already broken down by person liable and by period. Article 21.3 requires the certificate of that resolution to be attached, signed by the secretary with the chair's approval (the approval is unnecessary if the secretary-manager is a professional who will not act in the claim), stating the amount and its breakdown, together with the document proving notice to the debtor at the address he gave or at the flat or, failing that, on the community notice board for at least three days. We notify each of them: the buyer too must know what is being asked of him. And if the former owner has vanished, this is the only monitorio in which the court's demand for payment can end up being served by public notice, after an attempt at the address given or, if there is none, at the flat (article 815.2 of the Civil Procedure Act).

Before filing the petition, a settlement must also be attempted; the request can go out before the owners' meeting resolution, provided it concerns the same debt that is later claimed. Article 5.2 of Organic Act 1/2025 requires it in declaratory proceedings and in the special proceedings of Book IV of the Civil Procedure Act, where the monitorio sits, and what its paragraph 3 exempts includes the European order for payment, not the domestic one; some Audiencias Provinciales (provincial appeal courts) have required it in the community's monitorio, although other courts do not ask for it. Notice of the statement of debt is not in itself an invitation to negotiate, and, since the Act frames it as a request from one party to the other, it is best to prove it as against each defendant. That is why the proposal goes to the seller, the buyer and the registered owner, and if anyone's address is unknown, the law accepts a sworn statement to that effect (article 264.4).

The petition is filed with the civil section of the Tribunal de Instancia for the debtor's domicile or for the place where the flat is, at the community's choice (article 813), with separate requests: an order to pay against the personal debtor, and an order against the new owner and the registered owner to submit to enforcement against the flat up to the amount charged. If anyone opposes, the case continues as a juicio verbal whatever the amount (article 250.1.15), and a pre-emptive attachment can be sought without the community providing security (article 21.4 of the Horizontal Property Act); above 15,000 euros we make sure the court routes it that way, because article 818.2 still speaks of amount and a missed month ends in dismissal with costs. If the flat is sold once a title against the defaulter already exists, article 538.2.3 allows enforcement to be directed against the flat for the amount charged, and an enforcement claim needs no prior attempt to negotiate.

How we run the case, step by step

  1. 1

    Land registry extract and chain of owners

    We obtain the land registry extract and, where needed, the registry certificate, and rebuild who owned the flat and from what date: deed, award decree, death or sale to a fund. Each date produces a window, and the Registry tells us whom to sue as registered owner.

  2. 2

    Statement of debt split by person liable

    We sort the debt instalment by instalment into four columns: what each previous owner owes personally, what falls within the flat's window, what the new owner owes in his own right and what accrued after a sale that was never notified. We strike out what is time-barred and mark which instalments lapse first.

  3. 3

    Burofax and invitation to negotiate to each of them

    We send each person liable a burofax (a certified letter with proof of delivery and content) setting out his share and a concrete payment proposal. It interrupts the lapse period, meets the prior-attempt requirement of Organic Act 1/2025 and starts the thirty calendar days. If any instalment is about to lapse, it goes out the same day.

  4. 4

    Owners' meeting resolution and notice of the statement

    The owners' meeting approves the statement with its breakdown, the secretary certifies it with the chair's approval and it is served on each of them at the address given, at the flat or, if that is not possible, on the notice board with the formal record required by article 9.1(h).

  5. 5

    Monitorio against all of them, with separate requests

    We file the petition with the civil section of the Tribunal de Instancia (the first-instance court) for the place where the flat is or for the debtor's domicile, with the land registry extract, the certificate, the notices and the negotiation documents, and we ask for an order to pay against the debtor and for the new owner and the registered owner to submit to enforcement against the flat.

  6. 6

    Opposition, attachment and enforcement against the flat

    If nobody opposes, we seek enforcement and registration of the attachment of the flat. If someone opposes, we answer the opposition within ten days in the juicio verbal and seek a pre-emptive attachment without security. Whatever the flat does not cover is pursued against the personal debtor's assets.

The evidence that decides the case

  • The land registry extract or certificate showing each transfer and its date: it fixes the day from which the window is counted and who must be sued as registered owner.
  • The deed of sale with the seller's declaration and the debt certificate, or the buyer's waiver: it decides whether the community can pursue the buyer and whether the buyer can recover from the seller.
  • The minutes of the meeting approving the statement and the secretary's certificate with the chair's approval, broken down by instalment and owner: without a breakdown, the court cannot separate what is personal from what is charged on the flat.
  • Proof of notice to each person liable: the burofax delivery receipt at the address given, delivery at the flat, or the formal record of posting on the notice board with its date.
  • The minutes, receipts and emails showing whether the community knew of the change of owner: they decide whether the seller who gave no notice remains jointly liable or is released.
  • The documents of the attempt to negotiate with each defendant and the earlier burofaxes: they prove the admissibility requirement and the interruption of the lapse period for the oldest instalments.

What closes the door

  • Asking the new owner for the whole historical debt, or for a personal order to pay the previous owner's instalments. That part is dismissed and the community may be ordered to pay costs.
  • Counting the window from the claim or from registration in the Land Registry rather than from the date of acquisition: years that are not owed are claimed and others that are owed are lost.
  • Not suing the registered owner when the real owner has not registered: the attachment cannot be registered and enforcement against the flat stalls.
  • Waiting for the bank to finish its mortgage enforcement before claiming: the window is counted from the award and the debtor's oldest instalments lapse in the meantime.
  • Treating notice of the statement of debt as the attempt to negotiate, or inviting only one of the defendants to negotiate: the petition may be rejected as against the others.
  • Suing the seller who gave no notice as jointly liable when the community was already dealing with the new owner: the Act excludes that liability where the community knew of the change.

The law that applies

  • Art. 9.1.e) LPH. Requires contribution to general expenses; makes the community's claim for the part already due of the current year and the three previous years preferential; charges the flat, as against the acquirer even with registered title, with what is attributable to the part already due of the year of acquisition and the three preceding calendar years; and requires in the deed the seller's declaration with a debt certificate, unless the buyer expressly waives it. BOE-A-1960-10906
  • Art. 9.1.i) LPH. Requires the change of ownership to be notified to the secretary by a means that records its receipt; whoever fails to do so is jointly and severally liable with the new owner for what accrues afterwards, with a right of recovery, unless the community learned of the change by other means, through conclusive acts of the new owner or because it was common knowledge. BOE-A-1960-10906
  • Art. 21 LPH. Governs the community's monitorio: allows the registered owner to be sued to submit to enforcement against the property, requires the certificate of the resolution approving the statement with its breakdown and notice to the debtor, provides that on opposition the court orders a pre-emptive attachment without security, and places the lawyer's and procurador's fees on the debtor within the limits of article 394.3 of the Civil Procedure Act. BOE-A-1960-10906
  • Art. 538.2.3.º LEC. Allows enforcement against a person who, without appearing as debtor in the enforceable title, owns property specially charged with the payment where the charge derives from the law, and limits enforcement to that property. BOE-A-2000-323
  • Art. 20 LH. Bars registration of a claim, an attachment or a restraint on disposal if the registered owner is a person other than the one against whom the proceedings were brought. BOE-A-1946-2453
  • Art. 1966 CC. Sets at five years the lapse period for the action to claim any payments that must be made yearly or at shorter intervals. BOE-A-1889-4763
  • Art. 1973 CC. The lapse period for actions is interrupted by bringing them before the courts, by an out-of-court claim by the creditor and by any act of acknowledgement of the debt by the debtor. BOE-A-1889-4763
  • Art. 5 LO 1/2025. Requires, in civil matters, prior resort to an appropriate dispute resolution method in the declaratory proceedings of Book II and the special proceedings of Book IV of the Civil Procedure Act, with a closed list of excepted matters; its paragraph 3 exempts, among other cases, enforcement claims and the European order for payment, and the domestic monitorio is not among the exceptions. BOE-A-2025-76

Each article checked against the consolidated text published in the BOE (the Spanish official gazette).

Frequently asked questions

I have bought a flat and the community is claiming what the previous owner owed. Do I have to pay it?

Only part of it, and only with the flat. Article 9.1(e) of the Horizontal Property Act makes the property answer for what fell due in the year of purchase, up to the date of the deed, and in the three preceding calendar years; anything older is the seller's personal debt. If the community certified to you that nothing was owed, you have a defence that a good number of courts accept. And whatever you pay on the seller's behalf you can claim back from him (article 1158 of the Civil Code).

I sold my flat a year ago and the community is claiming from me the instalments the buyer does not pay. Can it do that?

It can, if you did not notify the sale to the secretary by a means that records its receipt: article 9.1(i) makes you jointly and severally liable with the buyer for what accrued afterwards, with a right to recover it from him. But that liability does not apply if the community learned of the change some other way, if the buyer was already acting as owner towards it (attending meetings, paying bills in his own name) or if the sale was common knowledge.

The flat now belongs to a bank or a fund and nobody pays. From when can it be claimed?

From the date it acquired the flat, usually by award decree or by deed of purchase, the flat answers for what fell due that year and in the three preceding calendar years, and everything afterwards is the entity's own debt. Anything earlier is claimed from the former owner. While the flat was merely attached, the bank owed nothing. Ask for the land registry extract: if the entity has not registered, the registered owner must be sued as well so that the flat can be attached.

The neighbour in arrears died and his children have inherited the flat. Are they also liable for only three years?

No. An heir is not a buyer: he succeeds the deceased in his obligations and, if he accepts outright, answers for all instalments not yet time-barred with his own assets as well (article 1003 of the Civil Code); if he accepts with the benefit of inventory, up to the value of the estate. If nobody accepts, the claim is brought against the estate pending acceptance, and the formal demand under article 1005 obliges the person called to inherit to decide within thirty calendar days.

I am about to buy a flat. What should I do about the community's debt certificate?

Insist on it and do not release the seller from providing it. The secretary issues it with the chair's approval within a maximum of seven calendar days, and both answer for its accuracy where there is fault or negligence. If it shows a debt, the prudent course is for it to be paid out of the price at the signing itself. Waiving it frees you from nothing: the flat would still answer for what fell due in the year of purchase and the three before.

This guide explains how the action works in general. It does not replace the study of your own case: deadlines depend on when things happened and on what you have done since.

Tell us about your case.

A lawyer studies it and tells you whether there is a claim, how long you have left and what can be sought. Your matter is quoted afterwards, because every case is different.

Other cases in this area