The defaulting neighbour opposes the payment order: ten days and attachment
Last updated 2026-11-10 · Reviewed by Jaime Piñeira Pardo, registered with the ICAM bar, no. 138826
The short answer
Once the neighbour objects, the community's monitorio (the order for payment procedure) continues as verbal proceedings (juicio verbal) before the civil section of the Tribunal de Instancia (the first-instance court), whatever the amount. The community has ten working days from service of the objection to challenge it, now with a lawyer and a procurador (court representative), and from that moment it can seek a preventive attachment of the neighbour's assets, which the court grants without requiring a bond.
You chair a community of twenty four flats. The owner of flat 3B owes 4,860 euros: eighteen months of fees and both instalments of the façade levy. The owners' meeting approved the statement of debt in March; as he never notified any other address, the recorded delivery letter went to the flat, came back uncollected, and the secretary posted the notice on the noticeboard with a signed record. He was offered a payment plan in writing and did not reply. On day nineteen of the payment order, his lawyer files an objection: he says he was never called to the meeting that approved the levy, that he paid 600 euros in June that do not appear, and that nobody approved the 350 euros of “management costs”. The decision you have just received opens the verbal proceedings and gives you ten days. And the flat is already advertised for sale.
The case, in five lines
- What is brought
- Challenge to the objection in the verbal proceedings into which the special horizontal property monitorio turns (art. 21 LPH; arts. 250.1.15 and 818.2 LEC), with an application for a preventive attachment of the neighbour's assets without security (art. 21.4 LPH).
- Before which court
- The civil section of the Tribunal de Instancia (the first-instance court) that admitted the monitorio petition (the one for the debtor's domicile or, at the community's choice, for the place where the flat is), which continues the case as verbal proceedings whatever the amount. The judgment is appealed to the Audiencia Provincial (the provincial appeal court).
- Deadline
- Ten working days from service of the objection to challenge it and, afterwards, five days to propose evidence (art. 818.2 LEC): these are procedural time limits that cannot be extended (art. 134 LEC), and a filing made after 3 p.m. on the working day following the last day is no longer accepted (art. 135.5 LEC). On the merits, each fee becomes time barred five years after it fell due (art. 1966.3 of the Civil Code; three years in Catalonia); the invitation to negotiate (art. 7.1 of Organic Law 1/2025) and the monitorio petition itself interrupt limitation.
- Who can bring it
- The owners' community, represented by its chair or, if the owners' meeting so resolved, by the professional secretary-administrator (art. 21.2 LPH), against the debtor owner. If the flat is registered in someone else's name, the registered owner is also sued so that the attachment and enforcement can reach the flat.
- Financial risk
- From the objection onwards, the community litigates with a lawyer and a procurador. If it wins in full, the neighbour pays the costs, including the fees from the initial petition onwards, with lawyers' fees capped at one third of the amount at stake unless there was recklessness (art. 21.5 LPH and art. 394.3 LEC). If it wins in part, each side pays its own. If it loses, it pays the neighbour's costs, unless he refused to negotiate without cause, and the attachment is lifted: not having posted a bond does not stop the neighbour from claiming the losses it caused him.
The objection turns the monitorio into verbal proceedings, whatever the debt
When the neighbour objects within the twenty days, the monitorio ends and the real lawsuit begins, and its judgment will have the force of res judicata (art. 818.1 of the Civil Procedure Act, LEC). What is specific to a community is the track: since 20 March 2024, article 250.1.15 LEC sends to verbal proceedings, whatever the sum, the actions under the Horizontal Property Act (Ley de Propiedad Horizontal, LPH) that concern money claims only. No new claim has to be filed: the letrado de la Administración de Justicia (the court clerk) issues a decision that closes the monitorio, orders the case to continue as verbal proceedings and serves the objection on the community. How objections work in general is explained in our guide on the debtor who opposes the monitorio; here is what changes when the claimant is an owners' community.
From that service, ten working days run to challenge the objection in writing and, once the challenge is filed or the period has expired, five days common to both parties to propose evidence and name who must be summoned as a party, witness or expert (art. 818.2 LEC). Those fifteen days decide the case. The challenge is the only document in which the community answers, ground by ground, what the neighbour says, and the proposal of evidence sets what the judge will be able to see, unless at the hearing the judge warns that it is not enough and allows it to be completed (arts. 443.4 and 429.1 LEC). If no evidence beyond the documents is needed, the court may decide without holding a hearing, so what is filed in those days is often the whole trial.
There is a nuance for large debts. The second paragraph of article 818.2 still speaks of amount: if the claim exceeds the ceiling of verbal proceedings, the creditor has one month from service of the objection to file a claim, or the case is dismissed with costs. It should not apply to a community, because its verbal proceedings have no ceiling, but if the debt exceeds 15,000 euros and all it receives is plain service of the objection, with no decision opening verbal proceedings, the claim is filed within the month and the point is argued afterwards, never the other way round. And because the community's verbal proceedings are determined by subject matter, the judgment can be appealed to the Audiencia Provincial (the provincial appeal court) even if the debt is below 3,000 euros: article 455.1 LEC only bars appeals in verbal proceedings determined by amount.
The preventive attachment without a bond: the law grants it, but it must be requested
It is the tool that changes the case most and the one most communities forget. Article 21.4 LPH allows the community, as soon as the debtor objects, to apply for a preventive attachment of enough assets to cover the sum claimed, interest and costs, and adds that the court will grant it “in every case” and “without the creditor having to provide security”. It is a head-on exception to the ordinary regime: whoever seeks an interim measure must show the danger that the judgment will come too late, provide prima facie evidence and post security, unless the law provides otherwise (art. 728 LEC). Here the law presumes that danger and waives the bond.
What the law does not do is grant it on its own: interim measures cannot be adopted by the court of its own motion, save for statutory exceptions that do not apply here (art. 721.2 LEC). That is why we apply for it with the challenge, or in a separate filing as soon as the objection is served, and many communities already announce it in the initial petition in case there is an objection. The application quantifies the principal, interest and a prudent sum for costs, and points to specific assets: the account the fees used to be debited from, which the administrator knows; the rent, if the flat is let, so that the tenant pays into the court's account; the salary, within the legal limits; and the flat itself. The neighbour can only free himself from the attachment by providing the guarantees laid down in procedural law, and for the community that is just as good: the money is secured.
The flat deserves a paragraph of its own. The attachment takes effect through a cautionary entry (anotación preventiva) in the Registro de la Propiedad (the Land Registry), and the registrar only makes it if the flat is registered in the name of someone who was a party to the proceedings. If the defaulter bought under a private contract, inherited without registering, or the flat is still in the previous owner's name, article 21.2 LPH allows the registered owner to be sued as well so that enforcement can be levied on the flat, and the Dirección General de Seguridad Jurídica y Fe Pública (the Directorate General for Legal Certainty and Public Faith) has upheld refusals to enter communities' attachments where the registered owner was not properly a party. If the flat is already advertised for sale, the entry is urgent: against a buyer who registers first, the flat only answers for what fell due in the year of the purchase and the three previous years (art. 9.1.e LPH), and the rest is left to be claimed from a neighbour who has just been paid.
Which objections succeed: payment, notice and items nobody approved
The most serious objection is payment, and it is almost never total: it is a missing receipt or a payment the administrator applied to another debt. If the neighbour produces the June transfer, the community must explain, with the statement of his account and receipt by receipt, which fees it was applied to; where the debtor did not say what he was paying, the Civil Code sets how the payment is allocated, and a table of charges and payments in date order defuses most of these objections. If the neighbour is right on part of it, that is acknowledged in the challenge and the figure adjusted: disputing a proven payment is the fastest way to lose the costs.
Article 21.3 LPH requires the certificate of the owners' meeting resolution settling the debt, signed by the secretary with the chair's approval (unless the secretary is a qualified professional administrator who will not act in the court claim), with the amount broken down, and the document proving notice to the debtor. That notice follows the order in article 9.1.h: the address in Spain the owner notified; if he notified none, the flat; and only if that is impossible, the noticeboard with a signed record, which takes effect after three calendar days. Once in verbal proceedings, many courts look more at whether the debt exists than at the formal defects of the monitorio, but a certificate with no breakdown or a notice given out of order hands the neighbour an argument. In Catalonia, the certificate must also state that the debt is due and matches the approved accounts in the minutes book, and include the demand for payment (art. 553-47 of the Catalan Civil Code).
Where costs are really lost is in the added items. The owners' meeting may set interest above the statutory rate against late payers, but never retroactively (art. 21.1 LPH); without that prior resolution, the debt accrues statutory interest from each due date. The costs of the claim may be included, those of the secretary-administrator too (art. 21.3), but with an invoice or receipt: a flat-rate, unsupported “arrears management” charge is the item courts cut most often. And fees that were more than five years overdue when first claimed are time barred (art. 1966.3 of the Civil Code; in Catalonia, three years). Every euro the judge strikes out turns a full win into a partial one, and article 21.5 LPH only charges the neighbour with the community's professional fees if the judgment is “entirely favourable” to it.
“The levy is void”: an argument that almost always comes too late
It is the most frequent objection and the one that least often succeeds. Owners' meeting resolutions bind from the moment they are adopted, and challenging them does not suspend their enforcement unless the judge orders it as an interim measure (art. 18.4 LPH). Anyone who disagreed had to sue the community within three months of the resolution, or within a year if it was contrary to the law or the bylaws (art. 18.3), and to do so had to be up to date with payments or deposit what was owed, unless the dispute concerned the participation quotas (art. 18.2). Once that period has passed, the action to challenge the resolution has lapsed (art. 18.3), and the neighbour cannot revive it as an excuse in the lawsuit claiming the fees. How a resolution is challenged is explained in our guide on the abusive levy; what matters here is the reverse: what is left to the neighbour who did not do so.
The exception the community must check before anything else is in the last sentence of article 18.3: for absent owners, the period runs from notice of the resolution in accordance with article 9. If the neighbour did not attend the meeting that approved the levy and the minutes never reached him in the order that article sets (notified address, flat and, only if those fail, the noticeboard with a signed record), his period to challenge has not started and his voidness defence is still alive: he can still challenge the resolution, depositing what he owes. That is why the first question when reading the objection is not whether the levy was fair, but whether the neighbour was at the meeting and, if he was not, how and when the minutes were notified to him.
Only the few resolutions that the Tribunal Supremo regards as void ab initio, because they breach mandatory rules, public policy or fundamental rights, escape the time limit; a resolution adopted without the majority the law requires is contrary to the law and the action expires after a year. If the neighbour has sued in parallel to annul the resolution and asks for the verbal proceedings to wait, the community opposes this under article 18.4: a challenge does not suspend enforcement. And the classic “I won't pay until they fix my damp” is not an objection: the duty to contribute under article 9.1.e LPH does not depend on the community fulfilling other obligations, and unquantified damage cannot be set off against a liquidated debt; that damage is claimed separately.
Lawyer, procurador and costs: who pays what once there is an objection
The initial monitorio petition requires neither a lawyer nor a procurador (arts. 23.2.1 and 31.2.1 LEC), and many communities file it through their administrator. The objection changes everything. Those same articles only exempt verbal proceedings whose amount determines the track and does not exceed 2,000 euros, and the community's is determined by subject matter. From the challenge onwards, the community litigates with a lawyer and a procurador (court representative) even if the debt is 300 euros; no application is acted upon without a lawyer's signature, and a filing that is not corrected in time is as if it did not exist. At Managora the firm provides both, and the procurador receives the notifications and files the documents on time.
For the neighbour, the rule in article 818.1 is less clear: his objection must be signed by a lawyer and a procurador “where their involvement is required by reason of the amount, under the general rules”. Some courts, reading that phrase, accept an objection without professionals if the debt does not exceed 2,000 euros and require them for the verbal proceedings, while others require them from the first filing. What almost none do is treat an objection without a lawyer as not filed without first allowing time to correct it. The community may raise the defect, but should not build its case on it: the merits are prepared as if the objection were flawless.
Costs follow the general rules of article 394 LEC, with an addition in the community's favour: if the judgment is entirely favourable to it, they include the lawyer's fees and the procurador's charges from the initial petition onwards, even though their involvement was not mandatory (art. 21.5 LPH). The limit is the usual one: of the lawyer's fees, the neighbour only pays up to one third of the amount at stake, unless the court declares that he acted recklessly, and that is why, faced with a baseless objection, we expressly ask for that declaration. If the claim is upheld only in part, each side pays its own; the Tribunal Supremo accepts that a substantial success may count as total, but that is for the judge to decide and is best not left in his hands. In small debts, what is recovered in costs rarely covers what was spent: the real lever is the attachment.
The prior attempt to settle: proved once, never repeated
Since 3 April 2025, article 5.2 of Organic Law 1/2025 requires an attempt at an appropriate dispute resolution method before declaratory proceedings and the special proceedings of book IV of the Civil Procedure Act, which is where the monitorio sits; for present purposes, only bill of exchange proceedings and the European payment order are left out. Courts do not apply it to communities in the same way: some check it when admitting the petition and others regard the notice of the debt under article 21.3 LPH as enough. What is clear is that the verbal proceedings arising from the objection are not a new lawsuit: if the attempt was made before the monitorio, it need not be repeated.
If the neighbour claims in his objection that nobody tried to negotiate, the community answers with the document. Article 10 of Organic Law 1/2025 accepts a document signed by both parties or, failing that, any document proving that the neighbour received the invitation or proposal, on what date, and that he could access its full content; if within thirty calendar days the first meeting was not held or no written reply was obtained, the negotiation is deemed ended without agreement (art. 10.4.a). A recorded delivery letter with certified content, or a certified email, that gives notice of the statement of debt and offers a specific payment plan does both jobs at once. What cannot be done is make the attempt afterwards: if it was made and not produced, it is proved; if it was never made, the risk is losing the case on a point of form and having to start again.
The prior attempt also weighs on the wallet. The request to negotiate interrupts limitation from the date the attempt to deliver it is recorded (art. 7.1), and after a failed negotiation the claim must be filed within a year (art. 7.3). On costs, article 394 LEC denies an award in favour of whoever refused without just cause the method to which he was invited, and exempts from paying them whoever proposed it and was turned down, while article 7.4 of Organic Law 1/2025 requires courts to weigh each party's cooperation. For the community, the letter the neighbour ignored is a requirement and an interruption of limitation and, if it is recorded that he refused to negotiate, also a shield against costs.
How we run the case, step by step
- 1
Fix the deadlines on the day of service
We count the ten working days to challenge from service of the objection and diarise the five for evidence. If the debt exceeds 15,000 euros and plain service of the objection arrives, with no decision opening verbal proceedings, the one month period to file a claim governs.
- 2
Apply for the preventive attachment
With the challenge or earlier, we apply for an attachment of enough assets for principal, interest and costs: the account the fees were debited from, the rent if the flat is let, and the entry against the flat, after checking with a land registry extract whose name it is registered in.
- 3
Rebuild the debt receipt by receipt
We check the statement of the neighbour's account against the bank, the minutes that approved budgets and levies, the notices and the attempt to negotiate. Whatever does not stand up is withdrawn before the judge strikes it out.
- 4
Challenge the objection ground by ground
Within the ten days, with a lawyer and a procurador, we answer each ground with its document: payment, with the statement; voidness, with the minutes and their notice; lack of negotiation, with the letter. If the objection has no basis, we ask for recklessness to be declared.
- 5
Propose evidence within five days
We propose the documents, the questioning of the neighbour and the testimony of the secretary or administrator who gave notice and kept the accounts, with the details needed to summon them. What is not proposed there only comes in if, at the hearing, the judge warns that the evidence is not enough and allows it to be completed (arts. 443.4 and 429.1 LEC).
- 6
Judgment, costs and collection
With the judgment we ask for the costs to be assessed, including fees from the initial petition if the win is total. If the neighbour appeals, we seek provisional enforcement, and the assets already attached are the first to be used for payment.
The evidence that decides the case
- The certificate of the resolution settling the debt, signed by the secretary with the chair's approval, broken down by receipt (period, item and amount): it fixes what is owed and why.
- The minutes of the meetings that approved the budgets and the levy, with those attending, and proof of when and how the minutes were notified to the neighbour if he did not attend: they decide whether his period to challenge began to run and whether the voidness argument comes too late.
- Proof of notice of the statement of debt at the address the neighbour notified or at the flat and, if that failed, the noticeboard record with the date, the reason and the signatures of the secretary and the chair.
- The statement of the neighbour's account with the community, reconciled with the bank movements, showing each charge, each payment and the receipt it was applied to: it is what wins or loses the “I already paid” objection.
- The invitation to negotiate with proof of receipt and of its full content (recorded delivery letter with certified content or certified email) and the subsequent silence or refusal: it opens the door to the lawsuit and protects on costs.
- The Land Registry extract and details of the neighbour's assets (direct debit account, lease, employer): without them the preventive attachment is granted but has no bite.
What closes the door
- Letting the ten days pass without a challenge, or challenging without a lawyer and procurador and not correcting it: the neighbour's version reaches the judge unanswered and the evidence is proposed blind.
- Not applying for the preventive attachment: the court never grants it of its own motion, and the neighbour who objects to buy time sells, mortgages or empties the account while the verbal proceedings run.
- Seeking an entry against a flat registered in someone else's name without having sued the registered owner: the judge grants the attachment and the registrar refuses it.
- Inflating the claim with interest the owners' meeting never approved, costs without an invoice or time barred fees: the judgment stops being entirely favourable and the community loses its costs.
- Giving notice of the levy minutes only on the noticeboard, without first trying the notified address or the flat: the absent owner's period to challenge never started and his voidness defence is still alive.
- Receiving, with a debt over 15,000 euros, service of the objection with no decision opening verbal proceedings and waiting for the court to channel it: the month runs from that service and ends in dismissal with costs.
The law that applies
- Art. 21 LPH. It allows all common charges to be claimed through the special monitorio with the certificate of the resolution settling the debt, signed by the secretary with the chair's approval, and proof of notice to the debtor. Debts accrue interest from each due date, and interest above the statutory rate requires a non-retroactive resolution of the owners' meeting. If the debtor objects, the court grants in every case, at the community's request, a preventive attachment without security, and an entirely favourable judgment includes the lawyer and procurador in the costs even if they were not mandatory. BOE-A-1960-10906
- Arts. 9.1.h y 18 LPH. The owner must notify an address in Spain; if he does not, the flat counts, and if notice there is impossible, the noticeboard with a record by the secretary approved by the chair, which takes effect after three calendar days. Resolutions are challenged within three months, or one year if contrary to the law or the bylaws, counted for an absent owner from notice; the owner must be up to date or deposit the debt, and a challenge does not suspend enforcement unless an interim measure is granted. BOE-A-1960-10906
- Arts. 250.1.15.º y 818 LEC. Actions under the Horizontal Property Act concerning money claims only are decided in verbal proceedings, whatever the amount. Upon objection, the monitorio ends and the case continues in those verbal proceedings: ten days for the creditor to challenge the objection and five for both parties to propose evidence, with a judgment that has the force of res judicata. BOE-A-2000-323
- Arts. 23 y 31 LEC. They require a procurador and a lawyer, except for the initial monitorio petition and verbal proceedings determined by reason of amount not exceeding 2,000 euros. The community's verbal proceedings are determined by subject matter, so after the objection that exemption does not apply; no application is acted upon without a lawyer's signature. BOE-A-2000-323
- Art. 394 LEC. It imposes costs on the party whose claims are all rejected, unless there were serious doubts of fact or law; where a claim succeeds in part, each side pays its own. Of the lawyer's fees, the losing party pays at most one third of the amount at stake, unless he acted recklessly. No costs are awarded to whoever refused without just cause the settlement method to which he was invited, and whoever proposed negotiating and was turned down is exempt from them, save abuse. BOE-A-2000-323
- Arts. 721 y 728 LEC. Interim measures are adopted at a party's request and not of the court's own motion, without prejudice to the cases the Act itself provides for, and as a rule require showing the danger of delay and a prima facie case and posting security, unless the law provides otherwise. Article 21.4 LPH is that exception in the community's favour. BOE-A-2000-323
- Arts. 5, 7 y 10 LO 1/2025. They require an attempt at an appropriate dispute resolution method before declaratory proceedings and the special proceedings of book IV of the LEC, save for the listed subject matters and the European payment order. The request interrupts limitation, the claim must be filed within the following year, and a document proving receipt of the invitation and access to its content suffices; thirty calendar days without a reply amount to ending without agreement. BOE-A-2025-76
- Art. 1966.3.ª CC. It sets five years as the limitation period for actions to demand payments that must be made yearly or at shorter intervals. That is the period for community fees, and it runs separately for each fee from its due date. BOE-A-1889-4763
Each article checked against the consolidated text published in the BOE (the Spanish official gazette).
Frequently asked questions
Do we have to file a claim now that the neighbour has objected?
No. Since March 2024 a claim for fees continues as verbal proceedings whatever the amount, and the letrado de la Administración de Justicia (the court clerk) orders it without the community having to sue again. What it must do is challenge the objection within ten working days and propose evidence within the five days later granted by a procedural order (diligencia de ordenación). If the debt exceeds 15,000 euros and you receive only service of the objection, with no decision opening verbal proceedings, file the claim within the month: arguing about it afterwards costs nothing, losing the month costs the case.
Will they really attach the neighbour's assets without the community posting a bond?
Yes. Article 21.4 LPH requires the court to grant the preventive attachment in every case and without security once the debtor has objected and the community applies for it; there is no need to prove the neighbour is about to hide assets. He can only avoid it by guaranteeing the debt. The risk lies elsewhere: if the community loses, the attachment is lifted, it pays the costs and the neighbour may claim the losses it caused him. That is why it is sought only for what is truly owed, not a euro more.
The debt is 900 euros. Do we need a lawyer and a procurador for so little?
After the objection, yes. The 2,000 euro exemption only applies to verbal proceedings whose amount determines the track, and the community's is determined by subject matter. If the judgment is entirely favourable, the neighbour pays costs that include fees from the initial petition onwards, but for the lawyer's fees only up to one third of the amount, unless the judge finds recklessness. In small debts, the attachment and the request for a finding of recklessness weigh more than the costs assessment.
The neighbour says the levy is void because he was not called to the meeting. Can he stop paying it?
Only if he is still in time to challenge it. If he attended the meeting, or was sent the minutes and let three months pass (one year if the resolution is contrary to the law or the bylaws), the resolution binds him and he cannot dispute it as an excuse for not paying. If he did not attend and the minutes never reached him in the order set by article 9 LPH, his period has not started: then everything depends on how he was notified, and that is checked before challenging his objection.
And what about the fees he keeps not paying while the case lasts?
The petition could include the approved fees falling due up to notice of the debt (art. 21.3 LPH). Later ones are settled at a meeting, notified and claimed separately; some Audiencias Provinciales (provincial appeal courts) also allow an order to pay those falling due during the lawsuit, and others do not. Meanwhile interest runs from each due date, and if the neighbour sells, the flat remains liable for what fell due in the year of the sale and the three previous years.
This guide explains how the action works in general. It does not replace the study of your own case: deadlines depend on when things happened and on what you have done since.