Law firm guidesReal estate and conveyancing

Your community refuses a lift or a ramp: how to compel it

Last updated 2026-11-10 · Reviewed by Jaime Piñeira Pardo, registered with the ICAM bar, no. 138826

The short answer

Law 4/2026 strengthened article 10.1.b) of the Horizontal Property Act (Ley de Propiedad Horizontal): the community must build, with no prior resolution, the ramp or lift requested by the owner of a home where someone with a disability or over seventy lives, within economic limits. After attempting to negotiate, you sue before the civil section of the Tribunal de Instancia (the first-instance court); if the owners' meeting voted against, within the following three months.

You are 81 and have lived in your flat since 1984, a third floor with no lift in a building of twelve homes in Valladolid. Since your knee replacement you climb the stairs gripping the banister and stopping on every landing, and some weeks you do not go out at all. An architect has found that a lift fits in the light well and puts the cost at about 90,000 euros, 7,500 per home. At the March meeting the proposal lost by seven votes to five: the owners on the ground and first floors say they do not need it. You pay 65 euros a month in community fees. The chair tells you that, without a majority, nothing can be done. You have heard that a law passed in October obliges the community, and you want to know whether you can demand it, what it will cost you and how much time you have.

The case, in five lines

What is brought
Claim against the community of owners for an order to carry out the mandatory accessibility works under article 10.1.b) of the Horizontal Property Act, to apply for the grants you have pointed out and to apportion the levy. If the owners' meeting rejected or postponed the works, a challenge to that resolution as contrary to law is joined (art. 18.1.a LPH). In Catalonia, a court application under article 553-25.5 of the Civil Code of Catalonia.
Before which court
The civil section of the Tribunal de Instancia (the first-instance court) for the place where the building stands, under the ordinary procedure, whatever the amount at stake (art. 249.1.8.º LEC). Negotiation must be attempted first (art. 5 of Organic Law 1/2025): the exception for support measures for persons with disabilities does not cover these works. Appeal lies to the Audiencia Provincial (the provincial court of appeal).
Deadline
Absent a resolution of the owners' meeting rejecting the works, the action to demand them has no special time limit: it becomes time-barred five years after performance can be demanded (art. 1964.2 of the Civil Code), and a new request opens it again for as long as the person still lives there. If the meeting rejects or postpones the works, the resolution must be challenged: the action lapses after one year if the resolution is contrary to law and after three months in all other cases, counted from the meeting or, for an absent owner, from notification (art. 18.3 LPH). Since the community will argue that the works were not mandatory, count on three months. The request to negotiate interrupts limitation and suspends the lapse period while it lasts and, if no agreement is reached, it only satisfies the pre-action requirement if the claim is filed within the following year (art. 7 of Organic Law 1/2025).
Who can bring it
The request and the claim belong to the owner of the flat or premises where a person with a disability or over seventy lives, works or volunteers. A tenant cannot bring it in their own name (they have the route of Law 15/1995, at their own expense), except in Catalonia, where article 553-25.5 also gives standing to the holder of a possessory right. The defendant is the community of owners, represented by its chair. To challenge the resolution you must have voted against it or been absent, and be up to date with payments or deposit what is owed (art. 18.2 LPH).
Financial risk
If the court concludes that the works exceeded the economic limits and you had not undertaken to bear the excess, the claim is dismissed and you will normally pay the community's legal costs, unless the case raised serious doubts of fact or law. If you win, all owners pay for the works according to their share, you included, plus the excess if you took it on. The expert report is paid up front. And litigation takes time: if the person stops living in the home before judgment, the case may lose its purpose.

What Law 4/2026 requires and what has not changed

Article 10.1.b) of the Horizontal Property Act makes mandatory, with no need for a resolution of the owners' meeting, the works needed to guarantee universal accessibility and, in any event, reasonable accommodations, as well as those requested by owners in whose flat or premises persons with a disability or over seventy live, work or volunteer to ensure them adequate use of the common elements, including the installation of ramps, lifts or other mechanical and electronic devices. The meeting does not decide whether the works are done. Under article 10.2.a), it only apportions the levy and sets how it is paid.

Law 4/2026 of 1 October rewrote that paragraph in its first final provision, with effect from 23 October 2026. Before, the works were mandatory if the yearly charge, after deducting grants, did not exceed twelve ordinary monthly instalments of common expenses, or if the grants the community could access reached 75%. The cap remains, but the paragraph now extends to universal accessibility conditions and brings four new features: if the community seeks financing, the cost is spread over as many years as the financing allows; the community is bound to apply for the grants you bring to its attention; if the grants actually awarded reach 70%, there is no cap; and the Act now states that the person concerned may ask the court to compel the community.

It must not be confused with the resolution under article 17.2: the meeting may voluntarily approve the removal of barriers or the lift by a majority of owners who also represent a majority of the shares, and the community then pays even beyond twelve monthly instalments. That route depends on votes; the article 10.1.b) route does not. The new third additional provision requires public authorities to budget funds for accessibility grants and makes promoting accessibility a priority in housing policy, but it gives you no right to any particular grant. And none of this applies in Catalonia, which has its own regime in the Civil Code of Catalonia.

Who can demand it and what must be proved

The request is made by the owner: the Act refers to owners in whose flat or premises the person lives, works or volunteers. If your mother lives in a flat that belongs to you, you make the request; if the flat is hers, she makes it, or whoever represents her. If the person is over seventy, age is enough, with no need to prove any limitation; if not, disability is proved with the administrative decision recognising it, and without one the community will dispute everything. You must also prove that the person lives or works there: municipal registration, an employment contract or a certificate from the volunteering organisation.

The works have to serve that person. The Act does not grant a right to just any works, but to those that ensure the person adequate use of the common elements for their needs. Article 2.m) of the consolidated General Law on the rights of persons with disabilities defines a reasonable accommodation as one that does not impose a disproportionate or undue burden and, in its wording in force since 23 October 2026, states that failing to provide one amounts to discrimination on grounds of disability. That is why the technical battle turns on whether a cheaper solution would serve just as well: a stairlift platform instead of a lift, a ramp instead of a vertical platform lift.

If the person who needs it is a tenant or usufructuary and the owner will not make the request, there is another route. Law 15/1995 allows them to carry out, at their own expense, adaptation works on the common elements that do not affect the structure or fabric of the building, after notifying the community with a technical project: the community has sixty days to object with reasons or propose alternatives, its silence counts as consent and, if it objects, the matter is decided in the verbal procedure (juicio verbal). The decisive difference is that the person requesting pays. In Catalonia, if the meeting does not approve the works, article 553-25.5 of the Civil Code of Catalonia allows a court to be asked to compel the community to carry out reasonable and proportionate works, also by the holder of a possessory right, and the court sets the amount by reference to ordinary common expenses (art. 553-30.3), with no twelve-instalment cap and no 70% rule.

The sums that decide the case: the cap, years of financing and 70%

The cap is measured like this: what each owner has to pay per year for the works, after deducting grants, may not exceed what that owner pays in a year of ordinary fees. With a fee of 65 euros a month, the limit is 780 euros a year. A lift costing 90,000 euros in twelve identical homes means 7,500 euros per flat: paid in one go, it is almost ten times the cap. With a fifteen-year loan, it is 500 euros a year plus interest and, depending on the terms, it fits. That is the difference the reform makes.

The reform has a loophole: spreading the cost over the life of the financing only applies if the community applies for financing, and the Act does not oblige it to borrow. What it does oblige it to do is apply for the grants whose calls you bring to it, so the first letter must identify them by name and deadline. If the community does not apply, it will struggle to argue afterwards that the amount awarded falls short of 70%: article 1119 of the Civil Code deems a condition fulfilled when the obligor voluntarily prevents its fulfilment, and that is the argument we take to court.

If the numbers still do not work, the works remain mandatory when the person who requested them takes on the excess. The Act does not make clear how that excess is measured when grants fall short of 70%: our position is that it is enough to cover the gap up to that percentage, which is usually far less than everything above the cap. The undertaking is offered in writing before suing, not in the courtroom, and the claim seeks it as an alternative remedy: if the judge does the sums differently, the case is not lost. And if the by-laws exempt commercial premises from lift costs, that dispute also changes the sums, and it is best settled before the levy is apportioned.

If the meeting says no or postpones it: the deadline that really runs

The works need no resolution, but the community usually votes anyway, and whatever is voted can turn against you. If the meeting rejects the works, or postpones them indefinitely pending more quotes, that resolution must be challenged, and the same claim seeks an order to carry out the works. The general requirements for a challenge (voting against and having it recorded in the minutes, being up to date with payments or depositing what is owed, seeking an interim suspension) are explained in our guide on challenging owners' meeting resolutions. What matters here is the deadline.

Article 18.3 sets one year if the resolution is contrary to law and three months in all other cases, from the meeting or, if you did not attend, from notification. The trap is that the refusal is only contrary to law if the conditions of article 10.1.b) were met, which is exactly what the community will dispute. If the court concludes that the works exceeded the cap, the resolution is no longer unlawful and the applicable deadline was three months. That is why we work with three months, not one year. If you missed the meeting, send the secretary your disagreement in writing within thirty calendar days of being informed of the resolution (art. 17.8).

If there is no resolution, because the chair does not call a meeting or the community simply stays silent, there is nothing to challenge: you sue for performance. That action has no special time limit and becomes time-barred five years after performance can be demanded (art. 1964.2 of the Civil Code); since the obligation arises from the request, as long as the person still lives there a new request opens a new period. The same applies to anyone whose lift was rejected before the reform: challenging that old resolution may now be impossible, but a request made since 23 October 2026 is governed by the new law.

Before suing: a request that also counts as negotiation

Since 3 April 2025, a civil claim is not admitted unless an appropriate dispute resolution method with the same subject matter has been attempted first (art. 5 of Organic Law 1/2025), and this claim is not among the exceptions. The one that mentions disability, letter c) of article 5.2, refers to court-ordered support measures for persons with disabilities, the ones that replaced the old declaration of incapacity, which are something else. And framing the claim as the protection of a fundamental right to skip negotiation puts its admission at risk: what is being sought is compliance with the Horizontal Property Act.

The requirement is met by negotiating directly or between lawyers, through mediation, conciliation or the opinion of an independent expert. What works here is a single letter, addressed to the community through its chair and its property manager, that does two things: requests the works under article 10.1.b), with proof of eligibility, the technical report, the grant calls and, if needed, the undertaking to bear the excess; and proposes negotiating that same subject, with a date. If the community agrees, an independent architect appointed by both parties can settle the technical dispute before trial.

That letter interrupts limitation and suspends the lapse period from the date on which the attempt to deliver it is recorded, but the relief is short: if within thirty calendar days of receipt the first meeting is not held or no written reply is obtained, time starts running again. With no reply, or once negotiation ends without agreement, the claim must be filed within one year of receipt of the letter or, where applicable, of the end of the negotiation, for the requirement to count as met (art. 7.3), and each party's attitude during negotiation will later weigh on costs (art. 7.4). Seeking interim measures before the claim, or enforcing the judgment, requires no negotiation (art. 5.3).

The claim, the expert and how the judgment is enforced

The community is sued before the civil section of the Tribunal de Instancia for the place where the building stands, under the ordinary procedure, which applies to actions under the Horizontal Property Act that are not purely for money (art. 249.1.8.º LEC). The claim seeks a declaration of the obligation and an order requiring the community to carry out the works within a set time, to apply for the grants identified and to apportion the levy, with tiered alternative remedies: the alternative technical solution, and the works with the excess borne by you. The court cannot grant what it is not asked for.

The case is won with the expert. The report of the architect we work with states whether the works fit and how, what alternatives exist, what each one costs, whether part of a private unit must be taken, and what it means per home per year, with and without financing. Against it will stand the community's report, which will say that it does not fit, that it costs more or that a stair chair is enough. If the lift requires taking part of a storage room or a flat, there is also a conflict with that neighbour, who must allow the essential easement and is entitled to compensation from the community (art. 9.1.c).

Winning does not install the lift. If the community fails to comply, the court orders it to carry out the works within the time it sets (art. 705 LEC) and, if it still does not, you may ask for the works to be commissioned from a third party at the community's expense, after valuation by a court-appointed expert, with seizure of its assets if it does not deposit the amount (art. 706). The reserve fund, which the Act also earmarks for these works (art. 9.1.f), is the first money available, and the flats and premises are charged with payment of the levy (art. 10.2.c).

How we run the case, step by step

  1. 1

    Prove eligibility and define the works

    We gather the identity document or the disability decision and the municipal registration, and the architect we work with studies the building: solution, alternatives, feasibility and cost of each.

  2. 2

    Do the sums before the community does

    We ask the property manager for the approved ordinary budget and the state of the reserve fund, identify the grant calls the community can apply for and a financing offer, and decide with you whether to undertake to bear the excess.

  3. 3

    Request and proposal to negotiate

    We send the community, by a means that leaves proof, a letter that requests the works under article 10.1.b), provides the grant calls and proposes negotiating on a set date, which also satisfies article 5 of Organic Law 1/2025.

  4. 4

    The meeting: vote against and get it recorded

    If the community calls a meeting, you vote against any refusal or postponement and we check that the minutes record it; if you do not attend, you state your disagreement in writing within thirty calendar days. And you stay up to date with payments.

  5. 5

    The claim, on the three-month clock

    After thirty days without a reply, or once negotiation fails, we sue: a challenge to the resolution if there was one, an order to carry out the works, alternative remedies and the expert report. If there was a resolution, we file within three months of the meeting.

  6. 6

    Enforcement if the community fails to comply

    If the community lets the court's deadline pass, we ask for the works to be commissioned from a third party at its expense, with an expert valuation and seizure of its funds if it does not deposit the amount. No fresh negotiation is needed for that.

The evidence that decides the case

  • The identity document proving age, or the administrative decision recognising the disability, and the municipal registration, contract or volunteering certificate placing that person in the flat or premises: without them there is no right to enforce.
  • The architect's expert report on feasibility, alternatives and the cost of each. It is the evidence that decides the case, because it answers the three usual defences: it does not fit, it is too expensive, another solution is enough.
  • The approved ordinary budget and the monthly fees, certified by the property manager: they are the basis of the twelve-instalment cap, and the community will find it hard to dispute its own figures.
  • The grant calls delivered to the community with proof of receipt, what the community did or did not apply for, the award decisions and a financing offer with its term.
  • The letter of request and proposal to negotiate with proof of receipt, and the community's reply or silence: they prove the pre-action requirement and establish from when the community was bound.
  • The notice and minutes of the meeting showing your vote against, or the notification of the resolution if you did not attend, with its date, and your signed undertaking to bear the excess if you offered it.

What closes the door

  • Suing without first attempting negotiation in the belief that disability exempts you: the exception in article 5.2.c) of Organic Law 1/2025 covers court-ordered support measures, not these works, and the claim is not admitted.
  • Counting on the one-year period to challenge the resolution that rejects or postpones the works: if the court concludes that they were not mandatory, the deadline was three months and the resolution is already final.
  • Having someone who is not the owner, such as the tenant or a son or daughter who does not own the flat, request the works in their own name: article 10.1.b) gives standing to the owner of the flat or premises.
  • Failing to give the community the grant calls in writing: without that information it is not bound to apply for them, and the 70% rule may never come into play.
  • Asking only for the lift, with no alternative remedies and no prior undertaking to bear the excess: if the community's expert persuades the court that a cheaper solution exists or that the cap is exceeded, everything is lost.
  • Installing the ramp or platform on common elements yourself, with no resolution or judgment, or stopping payment of fees in protest: the community can demand removal of what was installed, and an owner who is not up to date with payments cannot challenge without depositing what is owed.

The law that applies

  • Art. 10.1.b) y 10.2 LPH. As worded by the first final provision of Law 4/2026, in force since 23 October 2026, works for universal accessibility, reasonable accommodations and those requested by an owner in whose flat or premises persons with a disability or over seventy live, work or volunteer are mandatory without a meeting resolution, if the yearly charge after grants does not exceed twelve ordinary monthly instalments; with financing, the charge is spread over the years it allows; the community must apply for the grants the person concerned brings to it; with awarded grants of 70% there is no cap; the person concerned may go to court; and whoever requested the works may bear the excess. The meeting only apportions the levy and sets payment terms, and the units are charged with payment. BOE-A-1960-10906
  • Arts. 17.2 y 17.8 LPH. The removal of architectural barriers and the lift may be approved by a majority of owners representing a majority of the shares, and the community must then pay even if the yearly charge exceeds twelve monthly instalments; the vote of an absent owner duly summoned who, once informed of the resolution, does not state disagreement within thirty calendar days counts as a vote in favour. BOE-A-1960-10906
  • Art. 18 LPH. Resolutions contrary to the law or the by-laws may be challenged within a one-year lapse period, and the rest within three months, from the meeting or, for an absent owner, from notification; those who recorded a vote against, absent owners and those wrongly denied a vote may challenge, if up to date with payments or depositing what is owed, and the challenge does not suspend execution unless the court so orders. BOE-A-1960-10906
  • Arts. 5 y 7 LO 1/2025. In civil matters, a claim requires prior recourse to an appropriate dispute resolution method with the same subject matter, except in the excluded matters, among them court-ordered support measures for persons with disabilities, and it is not required for enforcement claims or prior interim measures; the request to negotiate interrupts limitation and suspends lapse periods, and the claim must be filed within the following year. BOE-A-2025-76
  • Arts. 249.1.8.º, 705 y 706 LEC. Actions under the Horizontal Property Act that are not exclusively for money are decided in ordinary proceedings; an order to do something is enforced by requiring the debtor to comply within the time set by the court and, failing that, by commissioning a third party at the debtor's expense, with valuation by a court-appointed expert and seizure if no deposit is made, or by claiming damages. BOE-A-2000-323
  • Arts. 1119 y 1964.2 CC. A condition is deemed fulfilled when the obligor voluntarily prevents its fulfilment; personal actions with no special time limit become time-barred five years after performance can be demanded and, for continuing obligations to do or not to do, time starts running each time they are breached. BOE-A-1889-4763
  • Art. 2.k) y m) RDL 1/2013. Defines universal accessibility and reasonable accommodation, which must not impose a disproportionate or undue burden, and, in its wording in force since 23 October 2026, states that failing to make a reasonable accommodation amounts to discrimination on grounds of disability. BOE-A-2013-12632
  • Arts. 553-25.5 y 553-30.3 CCCat. In Catalonia, if the meeting does not adopt the resolution, owners or holders of a possessory right who have a disability or are over seventy, or who live or work with persons in that situation, may ask the court to compel the community to remove barriers or carry out the required, reasonable and proportionate improvements; the court sets their amount by reference to ordinary common expenses. BOE-A-2006-11130

Each article checked against the consolidated text published in the BOE (the Spanish official gazette).

Frequently asked questions

I am over seventy and have no recognised disability. Can I demand the lift?

Yes. Article 10.1.b) of the Horizontal Property Act covers people over seventy without requiring them to prove any limitation: your identity document is enough. The request is made by the owner of the flat where you live, which may be you. What the community can dispute is the sums (the twelve-instalment cap, grants and financing) and whether a cheaper solution would serve you just as well.

What exactly are the twelve monthly instalments, and what changes if the community takes out a loan?

It is what each owner pays in a year of ordinary fees. If what an owner has to pay per year for the works, after grants, does not exceed it, the works are mandatory. Since 23 October 2026, if the community seeks financing, that payment is spread over as many years as the financing allows, which brings within the cap works that used to fall outside it. And if the grants actually awarded reach 70% of the cost, there is no cap.

The meeting voted against the lift before the reform. Do I have to accept that?

No. If more than three months have passed, challenging that resolution is risky, and after a year it is impossible. But that does not prevent a new request under article 10.1.b) as worded since 23 October 2026, with the grant calls and a financing offer. If the community refuses again, it is that new refusal that is challenged, within three months, and the same claim asks for the community to be ordered to carry out the works.

My 84-year-old mother rents her flat. Who has to make the request?

The owner of the flat, that is, her landlord. A tenant cannot demand in their own name works paid for by the community, although they can ask the owner to do so. If the owner refuses, Law 15/1995 offers the tenant another route: carrying out, at their own expense, works that do not affect the building's structure, after notifying the community, which may object within sixty days. Catalonia is different: the holder of a possessory right may ask the court to compel the community (art. 553-25.5 of the Civil Code of Catalonia).

If I win, who pays for the works and what happens if the community still does not carry them out?

All owners pay, normally according to their share, you included, plus the excess if you undertook to bear it, and the reserve fund can be used for it. If the community fails to comply, the court sets it a deadline and, if that passes, you can ask for the works to be carried out by a third party at the community's expense, with valuation by a court-appointed expert and seizure of its funds if it does not deposit the amount (arts. 705 and 706 LEC). Enforcement requires no fresh negotiation.

This guide explains how the action works in general. It does not replace the study of your own case: deadlines depend on when things happened and on what you have done since.

Tell us about your case.

A lawyer studies it and tells you whether there is a claim, how long you have left and what can be sought. Your matter is quoted afterwards, because every case is different.

Other cases in this area