The community wants to ban holiday lets: the resolution
Last updated 2026-11-10 · Reviewed by Jaime Piñeira Pardo, registered with the ICAM bar, no. 138826
The short answer
The meeting may approve, limit, condition or ban holiday lets with three fifths of all owners and quotas (article 17.12 of the Horizontal Property Act), never retroactively. A dissenting owner sues before the sección civil of the Tribunal de Instancia (the civil section of the first-instance court) after trying to negotiate: three months from the resolution, one year if it breaches the law or by-laws; for absentees, from notification.
You own an apartment in a building of thirty-two flats on the coast and have let it by the week since 2023, registered in your region's tourism register. You did not attend the September meeting, where eighteen neighbours voted 'to ban tourist flats, including those already operating, from 1 January' and a 30 % surcharge on their expenses. A guest collected the minutes from the apartment's letterbox and you read them three weeks later. The property manager tells you the resolution will be entered in the Registro de la Propiedad (the Land Registry) and that your silence counts as a vote in favour.
The case, in five lines
- What is brought
- For the community, the resolution under article 17.12 of the Horizontal Property Act that approves, limits, conditions or bans tourist use of flats, or raises their expenses by up to 20 %, executed as a public deed and registered. For the dissenting owner, the claim challenging it under article 18, with an application for interim suspension (article 18.4).
- Before which court
- The sección civil of the Tribunal de Instancia (the civil section of the first-instance court) where the building stands (article 52.1.8 of the Civil Procedure Act), in ordinary proceedings whatever the amount (article 249.1.8), after an attempt to negotiate (article 5 of Organic Act 1/2025). Appeals go to the Audiencia Provincial (the provincial court of appeal).
- Deadline
- Lapse period (caducidad) under article 18.3: three months from the resolution, or one year if it breaches the law or the by-laws (without three fifths, retroactive or with a surcharge above 20 %). For an absent owner it runs from notification under article 9, which also opens his thirty calendar days to object (article 17.8). A request to negotiate suspends the lapse period (article 7 of Organic Act 1/2025).
- Who can bring it
- The owner who recorded a vote against, the absent owner (ideally one who objected within the thirty days of article 17.8) and the owner wrongly denied a vote, if up to date with payments or after depositing what is owed with the court (article 18.2). The claim is brought against the community, represented by its president (article 13.3).
- Financial risk
- A challenge does not suspend the resolution without an interim measure (article 18.4). The loser pays the costs, with fees capped at one third of the amount at stake, which is valued at 24,000 euros if it cannot be assessed (article 394 of the Civil Procedure Act), and a party who asked to negotiate and was refused is exempt, save abuse. Continuing to let without protection exposes the owner to the cessation action, with loss of use for up to three years.
Three fifths of the whole building, not of those who attended
Article 17.12 requires, to approve, limit, condition or ban the tourist activity, even where this alters the constitutive deed or the by-laws, the favourable vote of three fifths of all owners who in turn represent three fifths of the quotas. That such a majority can impose a ban is no longer in dispute: the plenary First Chamber of the Tribunal Supremo (the Supreme Court) accepted it in October 2024 under the former wording, and the 2025 reform says so expressly.
The count is made on the whole building: with thirty-two flats belonging to different owners, twenty votes and 60 % of the quotas are needed, even if eighteen attend and all vote yes. The missing votes can arrive later, because article 17.8 counts as favourable a duly summoned absent owner who, informed of the resolution, does not state disagreement to the secretary within thirty calendar days. For the dissenting neighbour, staying silent means giving his vote away.
Three details change the result and hardly anyone checks them. Owners deprived of their vote for debts, whom the notice of meeting must list, are not counted towards the majority (articles 15.2 and 16.2). The owner of several flats counts, on the most widespread view, as a single owner although all his quotas are added up. And the matter must appear expressly on the agenda: voted under any other business, the resolution breaches the law.
Since April 2025, no new holiday let without express approval
Article 7.3, in force since 3 April 2025, reverses the starting point: anyone who wants to begin the tourist activity first needs the community's express approval, with the majority of article 17.12. The by-laws' silence is no longer permission, and anyone who starts without approval faces the demand to stop and the claim explained in our guide on the cessation action. To stop new tourist flats, nothing needs to be banned any more.
Why vote, then? Because an express resolution sets the rule in writing, can be registered against anyone who buys and allows what silence does not: conditioning the activity (a maximum number of tourist flats, rules of use, guarantees) or surcharging its expenses. First, read the registered by-laws: if they already ban economic, business or commercial activities, the Supreme Court has held since late 2023 that holiday letting falls within that ban, and the new resolution should be adopted without prejudice to that clause.
Anyone who wants to start must ask the president in writing, who will put it on the agenda of the next meeting (article 16.2). Without three fifths there is no approval, and do not count on a court granting it in the meeting's place. What can be attacked is an unequal refusal: approving for some neighbours what is denied to another in identical conditions may be an abuse of right (article 18.1(c)), which as a rule must be challenged within three months.
What can and cannot be banned: article 5(e)
The community does not ban 'lettings' but the activity in article 5(e) of the Urban Leases Act. Since 8 October 2026, under Royal Decree-Law 29/2026, still awaiting validation by Parliament when this guide was closed, that letter covers the tourist, for-profit assignment of all or part of a furnished flat subject to the tourism rules, for thirty-one days at most: tourist letting by rooms falls within the three fifths. If the decree-law lapses, the wording covering only the whole flat returns.
Everything else stays outside. The same decree-law brought within article 2 the letting of a room as a permanent or temporary home, and residential letting cannot be banned with three fifths. A resolution that simply bans 'short-term lettings', 'seasonal lettings' or 'room lettings' exceeds article 17.12 in everything that is not tourist activity: to that extent it changes the use of the flats, requires the unanimity of article 17.6 and breaches the law.
That is why the wording of the resolution is half the case. A deed that describes the flats as 'dwellings' is not a ban: the Supreme Court requires use restrictions to be express and clear. And in Catalonia this regime does not apply: its Civil Code requires four fifths of owners and of quotas to amend the by-laws and to set special charges for disproportionate use of common elements (article 553-26.2, letters a and e), with time limits of its own.
Non-retroactivity protects those already registered, not those already letting
Article 17.12 ends with a decisive sentence: these resolutions shall have no retroactive effect. And the second additional provision lets anyone who was already carrying on the activity before 3 April 2025, under the tourism rules, continue on the conditions and for the periods of those rules. Both protect a lawful position, not a factual one: someone who let through platforms without registration or a declaration to the tourism authority has nothing to preserve.
A comparison of dates decides: that of each flat's tourism registration against that of the resolution and, if it started after 3 April 2025, that of the community's approval. If the registered by-laws already banned economic activities, there is no non-retroactivity to invoke. The Dirección General de Seguridad Jurídica y Fe Pública (the Directorate General that reviews land registrars' decisions) applies this strictly: a flat registered fifteen days after the meeting was caught by the ban, and so was its buyer.
The protection has limits. It lasts as long as the authorisation and, on the most widespread reading, does not prevent the surcharge of up to 20 % being charged from the date of the resolution, because that does not look to the past. And the law protects 'that owner': someone who buys a protected tourist flat to keep operating it risks being required to obtain the community's approval. The law does not expressly resolve these points.
Registering the resolution: without it, later buyers are not bound
A validly adopted resolution binds all owners, whether or not it is registered (article 17.9), and is enforceable from the closing of the minutes (article 19.3). The Land Registry matters for those who buy later: unregistered by-laws do not prejudice third parties (article 5 of the Horizontal Property Act), the building's entry records the rules of the deed and by-laws that shape the exercise of ownership (article 8.4 of the Mortgage Act) and what is not registered does not prejudice third parties (article 32).
What is registered is the certificate of the resolution, signed by the secretary with the president's approval, showing the double majority over the total, the notification to each absent owner and the expiry of their thirty days, executed as a public deed. Time matters: every flat sold and registered between the meeting and the registration of the resolution opens an avoidable argument about whether that buyer is a third party whom the ban does not prejudice.
Two qualifications. The prior approval of article 7.3 binds any buyer because it is the law: registration matters above all for the ban, the conditions and the surcharge. And the short-term rental registration number the Land Registry used to assign, which registrars checked against these bans, fell when the Supreme Court annulled the Single Rental Register procedure in 2026; the regional tourism register still governs.
Challenging it: thirty days, three months or one year, and negotiation first
An owner who missed the meeting has two clocks: thirty calendar days to state disagreement to the secretary (article 17.8), because if he lets them pass his vote counts in favour of the resolution and the community will later dispute his standing, although article 18.2 grants it to owners absent for any reason; and the lapse period of article 18.3, which for him runs from notification. Both start with notification under article 9.1(h): at the address in Spain he designated or, if he designated none, at the flat, even if the occupant collects it, and, if that is impossible, on the notice board, with a signed note and effect after three calendar days.
The period depends on the ground. A resolution breaches the law, and can be challenged within one year, if passed without three fifths of the total, outside the agenda, with retroactive effect on authorised flats, with a surcharge above 20 % or banning non-tourist lettings. Unequal treatment or abuse of right must, as a rule, be challenged within three months. Once those periods expire, the Supreme Court only allows a resolution to be disputed in exceptional cases of absolute nullity.
Before suing, negotiation must be attempted: the challenge is heard in ordinary proceedings, is not among the exceptions in article 5 of Organic Act 1/2025 and, without the document proving it, the claim is not admitted (articles 264.4 and 403.2 of the Civil Procedure Act). The request suspends the lapse period, which resumes if within thirty calendar days the first meeting is not held or no written answer is obtained (article 7.1). It is not needed for interim measures before the claim (article 5.3), nor for the meeting or the Land Registry.
How we run the case, step by step
- 1
Today: written objection and an address for notices
If you missed the meeting, we notify your objection to the secretary within the thirty calendar days of article 17.8, with proof of receipt, and designate an address in Spain for notices (article 9.1(h)), so that no period starts running again from the flat's letterbox.
- 2
Recount the meeting's vote
With the notice of meeting, the minutes, the notifications to absent owners and the objections received, we recalculate the double majority over the total: owners, quotas, those deprived of their vote and the agenda. One miscounted vote can leave the resolution below three fifths.
- 3
Prove the prior position with documents
We gather the tourism register entry, the booking history, invoices, guest registration reports and tax returns, to prove that the activity was authorised and running before the resolution and, if you have no community approval, before 3 April 2025.
- 4
Get up to date and propose negotiation
We pay or deposit what has fallen due (article 18.2) and propose to the president, with the same subject matter the claim will have, that the meeting exclude flats authorised before the resolution and cut the surcharge to the legal limit. If the community refuses to negotiate, you are exempt from costs save abuse (article 394.4 of the Civil Procedure Act).
- 5
Claim within time, with interim measures
We sue the community before the sección civil of the Tribunal de Instancia (the civil section of the first-instance court) before the action lapses, allowing for the suspension, and seek interim suspension (article 18.4) of the surcharge or of the demand to stop and, if the resolution is registered, a cautionary entry of the claim in the Land Registry (article 727.5 of the Civil Procedure Act).
- 6
Judgment, appeal and the next meeting
The judgment can be appealed within twenty days of notification (article 458 of the Civil Procedure Act). Once the resolution is annulled, we claim back the surcharge paid and keep watch on the next meeting: the community may vote it again properly, and the judgment protects your prior position, not a building without rules.
The evidence that decides the case
- The notice of meeting with the item expressly on the agenda and the list of owners in arrears, and the minutes with each owner's name, quota and vote: with them the double majority over the total is recalculated.
- The notification of the minutes to each absent owner, with date, place and method (designated address, the flat itself or the notice board with its record), and the objections received: they decide whether silence counted and from when the period runs.
- The decision registering the flat in the tourism register, or the responsible declaration with its filing stamp: its date, against that of the resolution and 3 April 2025, decides non-retroactivity.
- The platform's booking history, invoices, guest registration reports and tax returns: the second additional provision requires the activity to have been carried on, not merely registered.
- The Land Registry extract: the date the resolution was registered against the date each flat's purchase was registered decides whom the ban reaches.
- The request to negotiate with its proof of receipt and the community's answer or silence, plus proof of payment or deposit: without them the claim is not admitted, and with them costs are argued.
What closes the door
- Letting the thirty calendar days of article 17.8 pass without notifying the secretary of your objection in writing: your vote is added to the resolution you wanted to fight.
- Not designating an address in Spain for notices: minutes handed to the flat's occupant, even a guest, or posted on the notice board start the periods running without your knowing.
- Registering with the tourism register after the meeting, or starting after 3 April 2025 without community approval, in the belief that this protects you: non-retroactivity only covers prior lawful positions.
- Relying on the one-year period when the only ground is abuse of right or harm: it is three months, and the court applies the lapse even if the community does not raise it.
- For the community: counting three fifths over those present without waiting for the absent owners' thirty days, or closing flats already authorised, or surcharging more than 20 %: it opens a year in which to challenge.
- For the community: failing to execute the resolution as a public deed and register it, or taking months to do so, and then facing buyers whom the ban does not prejudice.
The law that applies
- Arts. 17.8 y 17.12 LPH. Requires three fifths of all owners representing three fifths of the quotas to approve, limit, condition or ban the activity in article 5(e) of the Urban Leases Act, whether or not it alters the deed or the by-laws, and to raise that flat's expenses by up to 20 %, with no retroactive effect. Counts as favourable a duly summoned absent owner who, informed of the resolution, does not object within thirty calendar days. BOE-A-1960-10906
- Art. 7.3 y disp. adic. 2.ª LPH. Anyone wishing to carry on the activity in article 5(e) of the Urban Leases Act must first obtain the community's express approval on the terms of article 17.12, and the president shall demand that anyone doing it without approval stop. Anyone already carrying it on before 3 April 2025, under the tourism rules, may continue on their conditions and for their periods. BOE-A-1960-10906
- Art. 18 LPH. Allows challenges to resolutions that breach the law or the by-laws, those seriously harmful to the community or to an owner, and abusive ones; gives standing to the owner who recorded a vote against, the absent owner and the one wrongly denied a vote, if up to date with payments or after depositing; the action lapses after three months, or one year where the law or by-laws are breached, for the absent owner from notification, and does not suspend the resolution without an interim measure. BOE-A-1960-10906
- Arts. 5 y 9.1.h LPH. Private by-laws on the use or purpose of the flats do not prejudice third parties unless registered in the Land Registry. Without an address in Spain given to the secretary, notices are served at the flat, those handed to the occupant being fully effective, and if that is impossible, on the notice board with a record, effective after three calendar days. BOE-A-1960-10906
- Arts. 8.4.º y 32 LH. The registration of a building under horizontal property includes the rules of the deed and by-laws that shape the content and exercise of that ownership, and titles not registered or noted in the Land Registry do not prejudice third parties. BOE-A-1946-2453
- Arts. 2 y 5.e) LAU. Under Royal Decree-Law 29/2026, in force since 8 October 2026, article 5(e) excludes from the Act the temporary, tourist, for-profit assignment of all or part of a furnished flat subject to the sectoral rules, whose maximum length may not exceed thirty-one days; article 2 includes the letting of a room within residential leases, permanent or temporary. BOE-A-1994-26003
- Arts. 5 y 7 LO 1/2025. Prior negotiation is a condition of admissibility in civil declaratory proceedings, save listed exceptions, and is not required for interim measures before the claim. The request suspends the lapse period from the attempted delivery; the count resumes if within thirty calendar days the first meeting is not held or no written answer is obtained, and the claim must be filed within the following year. BOE-A-2025-76
- Arts. 52.1.8.º, 249.1.8.º y 394 LEC. The court where the property lies has jurisdiction, and actions under the Horizontal Property Act go to ordinary proceedings whatever the amount, except purely money claims. Costs fall on the losing party, with an exemption, save abuse, for a party who asked to negotiate and was refused. BOE-A-2000-323
Each article checked against the consolidated text published in the BOE (the Spanish official gazette).
Frequently asked questions
I have let to tourists since 2023, registered in the tourism register. Do I have to close because of the resolution?
No, if your registration and your activity predate the resolution: these resolutions are not retroactive (article 17.12) and the second additional provision lets you continue because you were already operating before 3 April 2025. On the most widespread reading, a surcharge of up to 20 % on expenses may apply to you from the date of the resolution, because it does not look to the past, although the law does not say so expressly. If the resolution orders flats already operating to close, challenge it within the year instead of waiting to defend yourself when the community sues you.
I did not attend the meeting and the minutes reached me late. How long do I have?
Two. Thirty calendar days from notification to state your objection to the secretary with proof of receipt, because if you stay silent your vote counts in favour (article 17.8), and three months or one year to challenge, also from notification (article 18.3). If you designated no address, delivery at the flat counts as notification, even if the occupant collected it, and, if delivery there was impossible, so does posting on the notice board with a signed note, effective after three calendar days (article 9.1(h)).
How much can my expenses be raised for having a tourist flat?
With three fifths, up to 20 % more than your share of common expenses, and only on the flat where the tourist activity takes place (article 17.12); above that, the resolution breaches the law and can be challenged within one year. Before challenging, pay or deposit what has fallen due: there is a case that this is unnecessary if only the surcharge is disputed, given the exception in article 18.2 for quotas, but it is not worth risking the admission of the claim.
We are the community. How do we register the ban in the Land Registry?
With a certificate of the resolution, signed by the secretary with the president's approval, showing the double majority over the total, the notification to absent owners and the expiry of their thirty days, executed as a public deed and lodged with the Registry where the building is recorded. Once registered, the ban prejudices anyone who buys afterwards (article 5 of the Horizontal Property Act and article 32 of the Mortgage Act). It should be done as soon as the count closes.
I want to start letting my flat to tourists. What do I need from the community?
Since 3 April 2025, its express prior approval with three fifths of all owners and of the quotas (articles 7.3 and 17.12). Request it in writing from the president so that it goes on the agenda of the next meeting (article 16.2). Without it, the president may demand that you stop and the community may sue you. And it does not replace the regional tourism authorisation or the town council's planning requirements: you need all of them.
This guide explains how the action works in general. It does not replace the study of your own case: deadlines depend on when things happened and on what you have done since.