Forced president or deadlocked meeting: the court decides
Last updated 2026-11-10 · Reviewed by Jaime Piñeira Pardo, registered with the ICAM bar, no. 138826
The short answer
If you have been appointed president and cannot serve, ask the court to relieve you within the month following your taking office (article 13.2 of the Horizontal Property Act). If the owners' meeting cannot reach the required majority, any owner may ask the court to decide in equity within the month following the second meeting (article 17.7). Both applications go before the sección civil of the Tribunal de Instancia (the civil section of the first-instance court), after an attempt to negotiate.
You are 79 and live on the fourth floor, with no lift, in a building of twelve flats and two commercial units that has never had a property manager: the president does everything, acting as secretary and manager, from the accounts to the bank. At the annual meeting three weeks ago, held at the second call, nobody volunteered and the presidency fell to you by rotation, even though you explained that a hip operation barely lets you leave home. At the same meeting, next year's budget, which raises the service charge to pay for the insurance and the cleaning, got seven votes in favour and four against; but those four, the two commercial units and two flats, held 52% of the quotas of those present, and the minutes recorded it as rejected. The neighbour on the first floor tells you the office is compulsory and nothing can be done. You want to know whether you can step down, who would replace you, and whether a court can unblock the budget before the community runs out of money for the insurance.
The case, in five lines
- What is brought
- An application to the court through the procedure of article 17.7 of the Ley de Propiedad Horizontal (the Horizontal Property Act), in three variants: relief for the owner appointed president (article 13.2, first paragraph), judicial appointment of a president where the meeting cannot appoint one (article 13.2, second paragraph), and an equity ruling on the resolution the meeting cannot pass for lack of a majority (article 17.7, second paragraph).
- Before which court
- The sección civil (civil section) of the Tribunal de Instancia (the first-instance court) for the place where the property lies (article 52.1.8 of the Civil Procedure Act). Whether the prior attempt at negotiation of article 5 of Organic Act 1/2025 is required here is disputed, and one Audiencia Provincial (provincial appeal court) has already refused to admit an equity application without it: we always make the attempt. Most Audiencias Provinciales allow an appeal against the decision.
- Deadline
- One month, a lapse period, counted from date to date. For relief, from taking office: the day of the meeting if you were there; if not, at the latest from service of the minutes. For equity, from the date of the second meeting, which the majority reading identifies with the meeting held at the second call at which the deadlock occurred (article 17.7). A request to negotiate suspends the lapse period from the attempt to deliver it (article 7.1 of Organic Act 1/2025). Appointment of a president where none can be appointed has no statutory time limit, but it is best sought within the month following the failed meeting.
- Who can bring it
- Only the owner appointed, whether by election, rotation or lot, may seek relief; the court names the replacement in the same decision. Equity may be sought by any owner with an interest in the blocked resolution, usually one who voted in favour, and those who voted against (the opposing owners) are summoned. Any owner may ask the court to appoint a president.
- Financial risk
- The court always rules on costs (article 17.7), with article 394 of the Civil Procedure Act as the reference: in principle they are paid by the party whose requests are all rejected, unless the case raised serious doubts, and a party who invited negotiation and was turned down is exempt unless there was abuse. If relief is refused, you remain president for the whole term; if you let the month pass, you can no longer ask the court for it in respect of that appointment. If the court rejects the proposal, the only course is to put another one to a new meeting.
The office is compulsory: saying no at the meeting does not release you
Article 13.2 of the Ley de Propiedad Horizontal (the Horizontal Property Act) provides that the president is appointed from among the owners by election or, failing that, by rotation or by drawing lots, and that the appointment is compulsory. The same sentence opens the only judicial way out the law regulates: the owner appointed may ask the court for relief within the month following taking office, setting out the reasons that support the request. It applies to any form of appointment, including someone elected by vote: what is weighed is whether you can perform the office, not how you came to hold it.
What does not work is what almost everyone tries. Refusing at the meeting, sending a letter of resignation or simply doing nothing does not remove you from office: you still represent the community in court and out of it (article 13.3) and, unless the by-laws or the meeting have separated the offices, you also act as secretary and manager (article 13.5). Meanwhile nobody calls meetings, nobody signs the certificate of debt the community needs to claim against an owner in arrears and nobody deals with the bank or the insurer; and for whatever you leave undone, your neighbours may hold you to account.
There are two ways out without a court, and they are worth trying while the time limit is protected. The first: the meeting may remove any officer before the term ends, by a resolution passed at an extraordinary meeting (article 13.7), and you, as president, can call it (article 16.1) with a single item, your replacement by whoever volunteers or by the next owner in the rotation. The second: if the burden is the work, the meeting may, by majority resolution, separate the functions of secretary and manager from the presidency (article 13.5). Neither of them stops the month of article 13.2 from running.
Which reasons persuade the court, and whom you propose as replacement
The law does not list the grounds: it refers to “the reasons that support” the request. The courts start from the premise that the presidency is a burden that comes with ownership, and lift it where there are objective and serious causes that prevent you from performing it or make it extraordinarily onerous, not out of mere inconvenience. Grounds that tend to succeed are advanced age combined with health problems, illness or disability limiting your independence, the daily care of a dependent relative, habitual residence far from the building or abroad, and a direct conflict of interest, such as a pending lawsuit with the community itself.
As a rule, lack of time because of work, not understanding accounts, a poor relationship with a neighbour or having been president recently all fail. What tips the balance is the real burden of the office in that building. With a professional manager, the president calls meetings, chairs them and signs; without one, the president also acts as secretary and manager (article 13.5), and the same age or the same illness weighs far more. That is why the application is not won with a stray medical certificate, but by explaining what the office demands in that community and why you cannot take it on.
The court decides “de plano”, summarily and without the need for a trial, so the evidence goes with the application and is not held back for a hearing that may never take place. If it grants relief, it must designate in the same decision the owner who replaces you until the meeting makes a new appointment within the period the court sets (article 13.2). An application that answers that question goes further: the vice-president, if there is one, who is already called on to stand in for the president where the president is unable to act (article 13.4), the next owner in the rotation, or a neighbour who has agreed in writing. If the flaw lies in the appointment itself (the rotation order was skipped or the item was not on the agenda), the route is to challenge the resolution (article 18), with its own time limits.
A meeting without a majority: the court breaks the deadlock, but does not overturn a no
Article 17.7 sets the general rule: at the first call, a majority of all the owners who also represent a majority of the quotas; at the second, a majority of those attending, provided it represents more than half the value of the quotas of those present. It adds that, where the majority cannot be achieved by the procedures of the preceding paragraphs, the court, at the request of a party made within the month following the date of the second meeting and after hearing the opposing owners, previously summoned, at a comparecencia (a short hearing), will decide in equity whatever is appropriate within twenty days of the request, ruling on costs. It is one of the few cases in which the law allows a court to decide on equity alone (article 3.2 of the Civil Code).
Deadlock is not defeat. The procedure is designed for a split majority: the proposal gathers more owners than quotas, or more quotas than owners, or ties. If a clear majority, of owners and of quotas, voted against, the meeting has decided no, and the sounder reading is that there is nothing to unblock: that negative resolution can only be contested by challenging it on the grounds of article 18 (contrary to the law or the by-laws, seriously harmful or abusive), within three months or, if it breaches the law or the by-laws, within a year. Choosing the wrong route uses up time limits that do not come back; challenges are explained in our guide on challenging resolutions of the owners' meeting.
Nor can everything be asked for. The court is asked for the same thing that was voted on, with the conditions that make it reasonable, not a different proposal. The wording reaches the majorities of the preceding paragraphs (one third, simple majority, three fifths), but this procedure does not serve to make up for the unanimity that article 17.6 requires to change the constitutive deed or the by-laws in resolutions that article 17 itself does not expressly regulate: the law speaks of “the majority”, and the prevailing view excludes that case. And there is no need to ask for what requires no resolution: upkeep works and the accessibility works of article 10.1, which Act 4/2026 has rewritten for people with disabilities or over seventy, are compulsory without any prior resolution; the accessibility works, with a cap: the amount passed on each year, after deducting grants, must not exceed twelve ordinary monthly community charges, unless the grants awarded reach 70% or those who request the works bear the excess. We explain this in our guide on the ramp or the lift.
When the month starts to run, and why absent owners change the count
Both time limits are one month long and are lapse periods: they are not interrupted by complaints to the manager or informal letters to the neighbours, they run from date to date, and it is unwise to count on August stopping them. The month for relief runs from your taking office: if you were at the meeting, from that very day. If you were not, the reasonable view is to count it from the day the minutes are served on you under the procedure of article 9, because nobody takes up an office they do not know about; but that reading can be disputed, and the prudent course is not to push it.
The month for equity runs from “the date of the second meeting”. Since 1988 the second call may be held on the same day, half an hour after the first (article 16.2), and the majority reading identifies that second meeting with the one held at the second call at which the deadlock occurred: the month starts that day. Do not wait for another meeting in the belief that it will be the second one. Arriving early can be fixed, because if a court required the vote to be repeated, it is repeated and the request made again; arriving late can only be fixed by taking the matter to a new meeting, which opens a fresh month but costs you months.
Before treating the proposal as lost, do the count with the absent owners. In resolutions whose majority is calculated on all the owners (three fifths, unanimity or the first-call majority), the vote of a duly summoned absent owner who, once informed of the resolution under the procedure of article 9, does not state disagreement to the secretary within thirty calendar days is counted as a vote in favour (article 17.8), except where the cost cannot be passed on to those who did not vote in favour or the work is for private use. A proposal “rejected” that evening may stand approved a month later. But the month of article 17.7 runs from the meeting, not from the end of those thirty days, and what lets you reconcile the two is the prior negotiation.
Prior negotiation: disputed here, but it is what buys you time
Since April 2025, article 5 of Organic Act 1/2025 requires in civil matters, for a claim to be admitted, a prior attempt at an appropriate dispute resolution method: in all ordinary and special proceedings under the Civil Procedure Act, save for listed subject matters, and not for enforcement claims, interim measures sought before the claim, preliminary disclosure or voluntary jurisdiction proceedings (article 5.3). Challenging a resolution of the meeting requires it. This procedure of the Horizontal Property Act is in neither the Civil Procedure Act nor the Voluntary Jurisdiction Act, which is why it is disputed.
Some liken it to voluntary jurisdiction, which the law exempts from negotiation (article 5.3). But in June 2026 an Audiencia Provincial (a provincial appeal court) upheld the refusal to admit an equity application filed without that attempt: it reasoned that equity is the standard for deciding, not the nature of the procedure, which is contentious, and that the meeting's deliberations do not count as negotiation. For relief from the presidency we know of no published criterion yet. We always make the attempt, in both cases: an application refused admission once the month has passed cannot be put right.
Nor is it a mere formality. A request to negotiate that properly defines its subject suspends the lapse period from the date on which the attempt to deliver it is recorded, and the count resumes if, within thirty calendar days of the other side receiving it, the first meeting is not held or no written reply is received (article 7.1); it is proved by any document showing that the other side received it, when, and that it could access its full content (article 10.2). Sent in the first few days, it leaves you almost the whole month for afterwards; sent on the last day, it leaves you one day. For relief from the presidency it goes to the community and the owners; for equity, to the opposing owners.
A community without a president: who calls the meeting and when the court appoints one
A community is not left without government because the president moves away, sells, falls ill or stops answering. If there is a vice-president, the vice-president stands in where the president is absent, the office is vacant or the president is unable to act (article 13.4). If there is none, the meeting depends on nobody: article 16 allows a quarter of the owners, or owners holding 25% of the quotas, to request it, and in the president's absence those same promoters call it, stating the items to be dealt with, the place, the day and the time, and summoning each owner at the address they have notified or, failing that, at the flat or unit itself (article 9.1.h).
That meeting may elect a president or, if nobody volunteers, appoint one by rotation or lot, and decide who handles the secretarial and management work (articles 13.5 and 13.6). If all the owners attend and so decide, it may even be held without notice (article 16.3). What is unwise is for a neighbour to act on behalf of the community without an appointment: that neighbour does not represent it (article 13.3), and the bank, the insurer or the court will point that out. The minutes of that meeting, signed by the president and the secretary, are what make its decisions enforceable from the moment they are closed (article 19.3).
Where, for whatever reason, the meeting cannot appoint a president (nobody attends, the rotation cannot be applied or the votes deadlock), any owner may go to the court for it to appoint one (article 13.2, second paragraph), through the same procedure of article 17.7. The law sets no time limit for this request, but the procedure is the one with the one-month limit and some apply it: the prudent course is to apply within the month following the failed meeting, with its minutes and a specific proposal of whom to appoint. In Catalonia the regime is different: the excuse is raised before the meeting itself (article 553-15.5 of the Código civil de Cataluña, the Civil Code of Catalonia) and the meeting is validly constituted whatever the attendance (article 553-23).
How we run the case, step by step
- 1
Day one: deadline and minutes
We fix the day the month expires, counted from the meeting, and ask for the closed minutes listing those present with their quotas and the names and quotas of those who voted for and against (article 19.2). If they do not, we ask in writing for their correction.
- 2
The way out without a court, in parallel
If you are the reluctant president, we call an extraordinary meeting with your replacement as the only item (article 13.7). If it is a blocked resolution, we check whether absent owners can complete the majority (article 17.8) and whether the work needed a resolution at all (article 10.1).
- 3
Request to negotiate in the first week
We send it to the community and the owners (relief) or to the opposing owners (equity), with its subject clearly defined and proof of receipt and content. It satisfies article 5 of Organic Act 1/2025 and suspends the month from the attempt to deliver it (article 7.1).
- 4
The evidence, before the application
Medical reports with diagnosis and limitations, disability or registered-residence certificates and what the office demands in that building; for equity, comparative quotes, a technical report and the split by quotas. The court decides on what it is given.
- 5
Application to the Tribunal de Instancia
We file it with the sección civil (civil section) of the Tribunal de Instancia (the first-instance court) for the place where the property lies (article 52.1.8 of the Civil Procedure Act) within whatever remains of the month: relief with a proposed replacement, or the equity ruling sought, with the opposing owners identified so that they are summoned.
- 6
Hearing, decision and what follows
We argue the application if there is a hearing. The court decides (the law gives it twenty days from the request), designates a replacement or rules on the proposal, and rules on costs. If the decision is not reasonable, most Audiencias Provinciales (provincial appeal courts) allow an appeal.
The evidence that decides the case
- The minutes of the meeting listing those present, their quotas and the names and quotas of those who voted for and against (article 19.2): they prove the deadlock or the appointment and identify the opposing owners whom the court must summon.
- The notice of the meeting with its agenda and, if there was a second call, its time: it fixes the meeting from which the month runs and proves that the matter was voted on exactly as it is put to the court.
- For relief, recent medical reports with diagnosis and functional limitation, disability or dependency certificates and registered residence outside the town: objective causes, not a generic note.
- The by-laws or the constitutive deed with the quotas and the rotation order, and proof of what the office demands in that building (without a manager, the president acts as secretary and manager): this is what turns a difficulty into an impossibility.
- For equity, comparative quotes, a technical report on need and benefit, and a table of what each quota pays: the court decides what is reasonable, and reasonableness is shown with figures.
- The request to negotiate with proof of receipt and full content, the reply or the silence, and service of the minutes on absent owners with their thirty days: they prove the prior requirement, date the suspension of the time limit and settle the count under article 17.8.
What closes the door
- Resigning by letter, refusing at the meeting or simply stopping: you remain president, you may be held to account for what you leave undone, and the month for relief runs out without your having used it.
- Waiting for “another meeting” because the law speaks of the second one: the majority reading counts the month from the meeting held at the second call at which the deadlock occurred.
- Filing the application without a prior request to negotiate, or sending it on the last day: one Audiencia Provincial (provincial appeal court) has already upheld the refusal to admit an equity application without that attempt, and the suspension only freezes the days that were left.
- Asking the court, in equity, to overturn a majority no, or to make up for the unanimity that article 17.6 requires to change the deed or the by-laws: that ground belongs to the challenge under article 18, whose three-month or one-year time limits keep running.
- Treating the proposal as rejected without counting the absent owners (article 17.8), or going to court with minutes that record neither names nor quotas: you litigate over something already approved, or without proof of the deadlock.
- Seeking relief without proposing a replacement or explaining what the office demands in that building, or asking the court for a proposal different from the one voted on: the court has nothing to decide with.
The law that applies
- Art. 13 LPH. The president is appointed from among the owners by election or, failing that, by rotation or lot, and the appointment is compulsory; the owner appointed may ask the court for relief within the month following taking office, and the court decides summarily through the procedure of article 17.7, naming the replacement. The court may also be asked to act where the meeting cannot appoint a president. The term is one year unless the by-laws say otherwise, and the meeting may remove officers at an extraordinary meeting. BOE-A-1960-10906
- Art. 16 LPH. The meeting is held at least once a year and whenever the president sees fit or a quarter of the owners, or owners holding 25% of the quotas, request it; it is called by the president or, failing the president, by the promoters. Without a quorum at the first call it is held at a second call without a quorum, on the date and at the time stated in the notice, which may be the same day half an hour later; failing that, it is called again within the following eight calendar days, with at least three days' notice; if all the owners attend and so decide, it may be held without notice. BOE-A-1960-10906
- Art. 17 LPH. Sets the majority for each resolution: generally a majority of owners and of quotas, and at the second call a majority of those attending representing more than half the quotas present. If the majority cannot be achieved, the court, at the request of a party made within the month following the second meeting and after hearing the opposing owners summoned, decides in equity within twenty days and rules on costs. Save for exceptions, a summoned absent owner who does not disagree within thirty calendar days counts as a vote in favour. BOE-A-1960-10906
- Art. 19 LPH. The minutes must state those present and represented with their quotas, the agenda and the resolutions, with the names and quotas of those voting for and against where relevant to validity; they are closed with the signatures of the president and the secretary within the following ten calendar days, from which point the resolutions are enforceable, they are sent to the owners, and their defects may be corrected before the next meeting. BOE-A-1960-10906
- Art. 3.2 CC. Equity must be weighed in applying the rules, but court decisions may rest on it alone only where the law expressly so allows. BOE-A-1889-4763
- Art. 52.1.8.º LEC. In proceedings concerning horizontal property, the court for the place where the property lies has jurisdiction, overriding the general rules of venue. BOE-A-2000-323
- Art. 5 LO 1/2025. Requires in civil matters, as a condition of admissibility, prior resort to an appropriate dispute resolution method with the same subject matter, in ordinary and special proceedings under the Civil Procedure Act save for listed matters, and does not require it for enforcement claims, interim measures before the claim, preliminary disclosure or voluntary jurisdiction proceedings. BOE-A-2025-76
- Art. 7 LO 1/2025. A request to negotiate that defines its subject interrupts limitation periods or suspends lapse periods from the date on which the attempt to deliver it is recorded, and the count resumes if, within thirty calendar days of its receipt, the first meeting is not held or no written reply is received. BOE-A-2025-76
Each article checked against the consolidated text published in the BOE (the Spanish official gazette).
Frequently asked questions
I have been made president by rotation and I cannot do it. Can I refuse?
Refusing, on its own, does not release you: the appointment is compulsory (article 13.2 of the Horizontal Property Act) and, until someone replaces you, you represent the community. You have two ways out: the meeting, called in extraordinary session, relieves you and appoints someone else (article 13.7), or you ask the court for relief within the month following taking office, setting out your reasons. Prepare both at once, because the month does not wait for the meeting.
Which reasons will the court accept to relieve me?
Objective and serious causes that prevent you from serving or make it extraordinarily onerous: advanced age with health problems, illness or disability limiting your independence, caring for a dependent relative, living far away or abroad, or a direct conflict with the community. Lack of time because of work, or not understanding accounts, is usually not enough. What the office demands in your building weighs heavily, and so does proposing who should replace you, because the court has to name that person.
The proposal had more votes in favour, but failed on the quotas. Can the court decide?
Yes: that is the case article 17.7 is designed for. Any owner with an interest may ask, within the month following the second meeting, which the majority reading identifies with the one held at the second call at which the deadlock occurred, for the court to decide in equity after hearing those who voted against. First send them a request to negotiate, which also suspends the time limit, and, if the majority is calculated on all the owners, check whether the absent owners complete it by staying silent for thirty days (article 17.8).
Our community has neither a president nor a manager. Who calls the meeting?
A quarter of the owners, or owners holding 25% of the quotas, may request and call it (article 16 of the Horizontal Property Act), summoning everyone with the agenda, the place, the day and the time. That meeting elects a president or appoints one by rotation or lot. If, for whatever reason, no appointment can be made, any owner may ask the court to appoint one (article 13.2); it is best done within the month following the failed meeting.
What if the court says no? Can I appeal, and who pays the costs?
The court always rules on costs (article 17.7). The reference is article 394 of the Civil Procedure Act: in principle they are paid by whoever sees all their requests rejected, unless the case raised serious doubts, and whoever invited negotiation and was turned down is exempt unless there was abuse. On appeal the law is silent: most Audiencias Provinciales (provincial appeal courts) allow it and check that the decision is rational and reasonable, although some refuse it.
This guide explains how the action works in general. It does not replace the study of your own case: deadlines depend on when things happened and on what you have done since.