A neighbour refuses access for the building's repair works
Last updated 2026-11-10 · Reviewed by Jaime Piñeira Pardo, registered with the ICAM bar, no. 138826
The short answer
The community requires the owner to comply with article 9.1(c) and (d) of the Horizontal Property Act (Ley de Propiedad Horizontal): to allow the repair or the essential easement and to let the workers in. The case is heard by the sección civil of the Tribunal de Instancia (the civil section of the first-instance court); there is no lapse period while the works are needed. If the fault is urgent, entry is sought as an interim measure, without prior negotiation, and from the order there are twenty days to sue.
You chair the owners' community of a 1965 building in Zaragoza. The main soil stack has broken at the level of flat 3B, where it runs boxed in beside the kitchen: flat 2B has a blackened bathroom ceiling, the staircase smells and the community's insurer insists that the source be repaired before it pays anything more. The owner of 3B refitted his kitchen a year ago and tiled over the inspection hatch. He will not let the plumber in: he says the community should find another route and that, if they want to break anything, they must first pay him for a whole new kitchen. Four months have gone by, he does not answer the property manager and the neighbour below is already talking about suing the community.
The case, in five lines
- What is brought
- Action to enforce the duties in article 9.1(c) and (d) of the Horizontal Property Act (to allow the repair or the essential easement and to permit entry), seeking an order not to obstruct the works, authorisation to enter the home and compensation for the damage caused by the delay (art. 9.1 of the Horizontal Property Act and art. 1101 of the Civil Code). If urgent, entry as an interim measure before the claim is filed (arts. 726.2, 727.7 and 730.2 of the Civil Procedure Act).
- Before which court
- The sección civil of the Tribunal de Instancia (the civil section of the first-instance court) for the place where the building stands (art. 52.1.8 of the Civil Procedure Act, Ley de Enjuiciamiento Civil), under ordinary proceedings whatever the amount (art. 249.1.8 of the Civil Procedure Act). The interim measure before the claim is sought from the court with jurisdiction to hear the main claim (art. 723.1 of the Civil Procedure Act), and the claim is then filed with that same court (art. 730.2). Before suing, an attempt to negotiate (art. 5 of Organic Act 1/2025), which is not needed for the interim measure before the claim or for enforcement (art. 5.3). Appeal lies to the Audiencia Provincial (the provincial court of appeal).
- Deadline
- There is no lapse period: the duty to allow entry can be enforced for as long as the works are needed and, being a continuing obligation, each refusal starts the five-year limitation period afresh (art. 1964.2 of the Civil Code). Damage caused by the delay: five years for the community, which claims breach of a statutory duty (art. 9.1 of the Horizontal Property Act and art. 1101 of the Civil Code), though it is wise not to go beyond one year; a neighbour suing under art. 1902 of the Civil Code has one year from learning of the damage (art. 1968.2 of the Civil Code). With an interim measure before the claim, twenty days from its adoption to sue (art. 730.2 of the Civil Procedure Act), suspended by the request to negotiate (art. 7.3 of Organic Act 1/2025). And the negotiation only meets the requirement if the claim is filed within one year of receipt of the request or of the negotiation ending without agreement (art. 7.3).
- Who can bring it
- Claimants: the community, represented by its president (art. 13.3 of the Horizontal Property Act) with a resolution of the owners' meeting authorising him to sue, and any owner who has suffered harm, for his own loss. Defendants: the owner of the flat or premises who refuses and, if someone else lives there (a tenant, a relative), the occupant as well, who is the one who has to open the door and who enjoys the protection of the home (art. 18.2 of the Spanish Constitution).
- Financial risk
- If the claim is upheld in full, the neighbour pays the costs, unless there were serious doubts of fact or law (art. 394.1 of the Civil Procedure Act), on top of the delay he caused. If the community loses, the costs fall on it. The interim measure requires security, lodged before entry (arts. 728.3 and 737 of the Civil Procedure Act), and if it is obtained and the claim is not filed in time, the community pays costs and damages (art. 730.2). If the neighbour refused to negotiate, the community is exempt from costs even if it loses, unless there is abuse (art. 394.4). Restoring the flat is paid for by the community (art. 9.1(c) of the Horizontal Property Act), and since it is not a natural person it pays the fixed court fee for ordinary proceedings, 300 euros.
Letting the works in is not a favour: it is a duty, compensated afterwards
Article 9.1 of the Horizontal Property Act imposes on every owner three duties that link together here. Letter (a): to respect the community's general installations, whether or not they lie within his flat or premises. Letter (c): to allow in his home the repairs that the service of the building requires and to permit the essential easements needed for works, actions or common services agreed in accordance with the Act, with the right to have the community make good the damage and loss caused. And letter (d): to allow entry into his flat for those purposes. The soil stack running through his kitchen is a common element even though it sits inside his home.
The Act covers two different degrees of intrusion. One is one-off access: the plumber comes in, lifts the tiles, replaces the broken section of the soil stack or the gas riser and makes good. The other is a permanent easement: a new pipe route through his false ceiling, or the lift shaft taking part of a storage room; this needs a valid resolution behind it and is scrutinised more strictly. None of this is the cessation action of article 7.2, which stops disruptive activities: here he is not forbidden to do anything, he is required to tolerate. And if the façade scaffolding has to rest on the property next door, which lies outside the community, article 569 of the Civil Code obliges its owner to allow it where it is indispensable, against compensation.
The right to compensation is not a key to lock the door. The Act grants him redress for the damage, not the right to be paid before opening up. He may demand what is reasonable: an agreed day and time, protection of furniture and floors, restoration with equivalent materials, accommodation if he is left without a bathroom or kitchen for several days, and his actual loss. Demanding a whole new kitchen up front is not reasonable, and that difference is what makes his refusal unjustified. If, when refitting, he walled up the inspection hatch or boxed in the stack, article 7.1 barred him from altering common elements and required him to give notice of his works: the community can argue that the extra cost of opening up falls on him.
The kind of works decides whether a meeting is needed and what he can dispute
Repairing a soil stack, a water or gas riser, or a façade that is coming loose is upkeep. Article 10.1(a) makes compulsory, without any prior resolution of the meeting, the works needed to maintain the building and its common installations, including those for safety and habitability, and the meeting only decides how the levy is shared out (art. 10.2(a)). The property manager orders urgent repairs, informing the president immediately (art. 20.1(c)), and anyone who notices an urgent fault must report it without delay (art. 7.1). If there is also a municipal enforcement order, an owner who opposes it or delays it without justification is personally liable for the administrative penalties (art. 10.2(b)).
Lifts and ramps have their own regime. Article 10.1(b), as worded by Act 4/2026 in force since 23 October 2026, makes compulsory the works needed for universal accessibility and those requested by owners in whose home people with disabilities or people over seventy live, work or volunteer, provided the annual amount passed on, after deducting grants, does not exceed twelve ordinary monthly instalments of common expenses, or without that cap if the grants actually awarded reach seventy per cent; and they remain compulsory even if the grants fall short of that percentage or the cap is exceeded, provided those who requested them bear the excess. Outside those cases, a lift is approved by a majority of owners and of quotas (art. 17.2). The Tribunal Supremo (Spain's Supreme Court) has held that this majority is enough to impose an easement over part of a privately owned element, without its owner's consent and with compensation, provided it does not cost him habitability or functionality. The limit is set by article 17.4: no innovation may make any part of the building unusable for an owner without his express consent.
A valid resolution binds all owners (art. 17.9), including the one who voted against. If the neighbour disagreed with the lift or the route, he had to challenge it: three months from the meeting, or one year where the resolution breaches the law or the by-laws, and for an absent owner from notification (art. 18.3), while up to date with payments or depositing what he owes (art. 18.2). Even when challenged, the resolution is carried out unless the court suspends it as an interim measure (art. 18.4). Once the period has passed, and barring a radical nullity that is exceptional, the access case no longer discusses whether the lift was a good idea: only whether his flat is the essential route, how much is taken and how much compensation he is owed. How a challenge works is explained in our guide on challenging resolutions of the owners' meeting.
The expert wins the case: a common fault and an essential route
The word that decides the case is in the Act itself: essential easements. The neighbour's defence is nearly always the same, that there is another route: via the façade, the courtyard or the flat next door. That is why the claim is won with a report from the expert we work with stating where the fault is, that the element is common, why access through that home is the only reasonable one, which alternatives were studied and what they would cost, what will be lifted, how many days it will take and how it will be restored. In Catalonia, where the Catalan Civil Code applies instead of the Horizontal Property Act, article 553-39 says so expressly: the restriction is only allowed if there is no other way to do the works or the other way is disproportionately expensive or burdensome, and the community can require permanent easements over the annexes of privately used elements where they are indispensable to carry out resolutions removing architectural barriers or making improvements, or to reach common elements that have no other access.
Before demanding anything, you must know whose fault it is. If the water comes from the drain that serves only his flat, before it joins the stack, in the view taken by most courts the installation is private: article 9.1(b) obliges him to maintain it and to make good the damage it causes, and the case turns around, because then the works and the bill are his. If the break is in the stack or in the main riser, the works belong to the community. A camera inspection fed down the stack itself, from the roof or from a common access point, can locate the break without entering his home, and that report is the evidence that supports the interim measure.
The court weighs the intrusion, and the community must arrive with a plan that keeps it to a minimum: specific days and hours, duration, an insured contractor, protection of the home, restoration with equivalent materials and an offer of compensation for whatever cannot be restored. That plan, sent in writing before suing, does two jobs. It defines the subject of the prior negotiation required by Organic Act 1/2025. And if the neighbour rejects it without reasons, his refusal is left without justification before the court, which is what later places the damage caused by the delay, and the costs, on him.
If the damage is spreading, entry is sought as an interim measure
When water keeps coming through, a leak forces the gas to be cut off for the whole building or the façade threatens to come away, waiting for the judgment is not an option. Article 730.2 of the Civil Procedure Act allows interim measures to be sought before the claim if reasons of urgency or necessity are put forward and proved, and article 5.3 of Organic Act 1/2025 exempts that application from the prior attempt to negotiate. The measure can order the neighbour to allow entry and to refrain from obstructing the works: article 726.2 allows orders with content similar to what is sought in the case, on a temporary basis, and article 727.7 an order to refrain from a course of conduct. If the urgency justifies it, the court can grant it without hearing him, by an order issued within five days against which there is no appeal, although the neighbour can oppose it afterwards (art. 733.2).
The court requires three things. Risk from delay: that, without the measure, the damage will worsen or the judgment will come too late (art. 728.1). A prima facie case: the technical report, the formal demand with his refusal and the meeting's resolution (art. 728.2). And security, lodged before any step to carry out the measure (arts. 728.3 and 737). Once it is lodged, the measure is carried out at once with the means used to enforce judgments (art. 738.1): in practice, a locksmith and, if needed, police assistance. Because the measure anticipates what is sought in the case, the court will be demanding, and that is where the report and the offer to restore carry weight. The mistake that sinks it is in article 728.1 itself: no measures are granted to alter situations accepted for a long time, unless it is justified why they were not sought earlier. A community that has tolerated the leak for a year will have to explain what has changed.
There is a shortcut few people know about when what is blocked is not his home but a common element in general use: the padlock the top-floor neighbour put on the roof door, or the meter room he filled with junk. There the community does not need to enter anyone's home. It can seek summary protection of possession through the juicio verbal, the shorter form of civil proceedings (art. 250.1.4 of the Civil Procedure Act), which is exempt from prior negotiation (art. 5.2(e) of Organic Act 1/2025), with a strict limit: the claim is not admitted once one year has passed since the act of interference (art. 439.1 of the Civil Procedure Act).
Negotiate, authorise and sue without falling into the twenty-day trap
A measure obtained before the claim lapses if the claim is not filed with the same court within twenty days of its adoption: it is lifted, the applicant is ordered to pay the costs and is declared liable for the damage caused (art. 730.2 of the Civil Procedure Act). Since the claim does require prior negotiation, Organic Act 1/2025 coordinates the two: if the interim measures were granted before the negotiation was opened, the request suspends those twenty days, which resume, rather than start again, when the negotiation ends without agreement; if they were granted during the negotiation, there are twenty days from when it ends (art. 7.3). That is why we send the request to negotiate on the same day we apply for the measure. And even if the stack has already been repaired, the claim is filed: otherwise the community bears the costs and the damage of the interim measure.
Prior negotiation is a condition for the claim to be admitted (art. 5 of Organic Act 1/2025), and this action is not among the exceptions. Direct negotiation between the parties or their lawyers counts, as does a binding confidential offer, conciliation or mediation, always on the same subject as the later case. It is proved with a document signed by both parties or, if the neighbour does not cooperate, with proof that he received the request and could access its full content (art. 10.2). If within thirty calendar days of receipt the first meeting is not held or no written reply is obtained, the negotiation is deemed ended (art. 10.4(a)), and without that document the claim is not admitted (arts. 264.4 and 403.2 of the Civil Procedure Act). Refusing has a price: if the neighbour refused to negotiate, the community is exempt from costs even if it loses, unless there is abuse (art. 394.4 of the Civil Procedure Act), and if he refused without just cause he would get no costs order in his favour even if he won (art. 394.1).
The president represents the community in court (art. 13.3 of the Horizontal Property Act), but the Tribunal Supremo requires, unless the by-laws say otherwise, a resolution of the meeting authorising him to sue. If it is urgent, the extraordinary meeting is called with as much notice as possible so that it reaches everyone (art. 16.3), and the same resolution authorises both the interim measure and the claim. The claim goes to the Tribunal de Instancia for the place where the building stands (art. 52.1.8 of the Civil Procedure Act), under ordinary proceedings whatever the amount (art. 249.1.8), against the owner and, if someone else lives there, against the occupant too. It asks that they be ordered to allow entry on the dates set by the works supervisor and not to obstruct the works, that entry with a locksmith and police assistance be authorised if they do not open up, and that whoever is responsible pay for the damage caused by the delay.
Enforcing the order and charging the delay to whoever caused it
The judgment is enforced without prior negotiation (art. 5.3 of Organic Act 1/2025). The order opening enforcement requires the neighbour to comply within the period set by the court and may warn him of personal coercive measures or fines (arts. 699 and 705 of the Civil Procedure Act). An order not to obstruct the works is an order not to do something: if he breaches it, he is required to undo what he did, pay compensation and not repeat it, with a warning that he will commit the offence of disobeying the court, and fines for each month (art. 710). What really unlocks the situation is entry. Article 18.2 of the Spanish Constitution only allows a home to be entered with the consent of the person entitled or a court decision, and a judgment that expressly authorises entry is that decision. That is why it is asked for in the claim and not left for enforcement.
The delay has someone responsible for it. If the refusal was unjustified, the neighbour is liable for what waiting cost: the worsening of the fault, the extra cost of the works and of the wasted call-outs, the administrative penalties and whatever the community has had to pay the neighbour below. The basis is breach of a statutory duty (art. 9.1(c) and (d) of the Horizontal Property Act, read with art. 1101 of the Civil Code), and it is joined to the same claim. The general period for personal actions is five years (art. 1964.2 of the Civil Code), but do not push it: if the court classifies the claim under article 1902, the period is one year from when the damage became known (art. 1968.2 of the Civil Code). Keep every invoice and every visit documented with its date.
If you are the neighbour below, do not depend on the community. You can claim your loss from the community, which must keep the stack in repair, and from the owner who is blocking the repair, who is answerable to the other owners for the damage he causes (art. 9.1(g) of the Horizontal Property Act). Suing both stops each of them from blaming the other at trial. If you rely on article 1902 of the Civil Code, you have one year from learning of the damage (art. 1968.2), which is interrupted by an out-of-court claim you can prove (art. 1973) or by the request to negotiate (art. 7.1 of Organic Act 1/2025). When water keeps coming in, the courts usually count from when the damage stabilises, but do not take that for granted: claim in writing now.
How we run the case, step by step
- 1
Technical report before any letter
Our expert locates the fault, with a camera where possible, and establishes that the element is common, why access through that home is the only reasonable one, which alternatives were ruled out, how long the works will take and how they will be made good.
- 2
Written proposal with dates, safeguards and compensation
We send by burofax with certified content, to the owner at the address he gave the community and to the occupant, the works plan and the offer of restoration and compensation. That letter is the request to negotiate: it interrupts limitation and opens the thirty days.
- 3
Extraordinary meeting with the authorisation
We call it with as much notice as possible if it is urgent. The meeting approves the works if needed and authorises the president to apply for the interim measure and to sue; whoever acts as secretary certifies the resolution.
- 4
Interim entry if the damage is spreading
We apply for the measure before the claim, without hearing the neighbour if the urgency justifies it, lodge the security and coordinate with the court officers the day of entry, the locksmith and the repair contractor.
- 5
Claim for compliance and damages
Within the twenty days after the interim measure, with the period suspended while the negotiation runs, or, without an interim measure, within one year of receipt of the request or of the end of the negotiation, we sue the owner and the occupant, enclosing the report, the negotiation document and the meeting's certificate.
- 6
Enforcement and the bill for the delay
If he does not comply, we seek enforcement with entry and coercive measures. Once the fault is repaired, we quantify the worsening, the extra costs and what was paid to the neighbour below, and claim them from whoever blocked the works.
The evidence that decides the case
- Our expert's report, with a camera inspection where possible: it places the break in the common element, explains why passing through that home is essential and puts a value on the alternatives ruled out.
- The burofax with certified content and proof of delivery carrying the works plan and the offer of compensation, and the neighbour's reply or silence: it proves the unjustified refusal and the attempt to negotiate.
- The reports of the contractor who came and could not get in, with day and time, and the messages in which the neighbour refuses or sets conditions.
- Dated photos and videos of the spreading damage, the insurer's report and the quotes from before and from now: they support the urgency and put a figure on the delay.
- The certificate of the meeting's resolution and, for a lift, the minutes with the majority obtained and the date it was notified to the neighbour, which shows whether he challenged it in time.
- The Land Registry extract and proof of who occupies the home: they determine whom to sue.
What closes the door
- Entering without consent or a court decision: with a locksmith, with the caretaker's key or by breaking through from the flat next door. It breaches article 18.2 of the Spanish Constitution, exposes whoever enters to a criminal complaint and hands the neighbour the case.
- Obtaining the interim measure and letting the twenty days pass without suing or sending the request to negotiate that suspends them: the measure is lifted and the community pays costs and damages (art. 730.2 of the Civil Procedure Act).
- Putting up with the refusal for months and only then applying for the measure: article 728.1 of the Civil Procedure Act prevents interim measures from altering situations accepted for a long time unless the delay is justified.
- Suing without the document proving the prior negotiation, or on a subject different from the one negotiated: the claim is not admitted (arts. 264.4 and 403.2 of the Civil Procedure Act).
- Suing only the owner when a tenant or a relative lives in the home: the authorisation to enter does not reach an occupant who was not a party, and it is the occupant whose home is protected.
- Going to trial without an expert who places the fault in the common element and rules out the alternatives: the neighbour will say the problem lies elsewhere or that there is another route, and the case becomes one word against another.
The law that applies
- Art. 9.1 LPH. Obliges every owner to respect the general installations whether or not they lie within his flat, to allow in his home the repairs the service of the building requires and the essential easements for works, actions or common services agreed in accordance with the Act, with the right to have the community make good the damage, to allow entry for those purposes and to answer to the other owners for the damage he causes. BOE-A-1960-10906
- Arts. 10.1, 17.4 y 18 LPH. Make upkeep works compulsory without a prior resolution of the meeting and, on the terms of article 10.1(b), accessibility works as well; forbid innovations that make part of the building unusable for an owner without his express consent; and set the period to challenge resolutions at three months, or one year if they breach the law or the by-laws, without the challenge suspending their execution unless an interim measure is granted. BOE-A-1960-10906
- Arts. 52.1.8.º y 249.1.8.º LEC. In horizontal property cases the court for the place where the property stands has jurisdiction, and the actions the Horizontal Property Act grants to owners' meetings and to owners are decided in ordinary proceedings, whatever the amount, unless they concern purely money claims. BOE-A-2000-323
- Arts. 726, 728, 730 y 733 LEC. Allow interim orders with content similar to what is sought in the case; require risk from delay, a prima facie case and security, and refuse the measure against situations accepted for a long time without justification; allow it to be sought before the claim on grounds of urgency, with twenty days to sue on pain of costs and damages, and to be granted without hearing the defendant, within five days, where urgency justifies it. BOE-A-2000-323
- Arts. 699 y 710 LEC. When enforcing orders to do or not to do something, the enforcement order requires the debtor to comply within the period set by the court, with a possible warning of personal coercive measures or fines; if he breaches an order not to do something, he is required to undo the wrong, compensate and not repeat it, with a warning of disobedience and fines for each month. BOE-A-2000-323
- Arts. 5 y 7 LO 1/2025. Require, in civil matters, prior resort to an appropriate dispute resolution method on the same subject, except for enforcement claims, interim measures before the claim and listed matters such as summary protection of possession; the request to negotiate interrupts limitation, the claim must be filed within the following year and, if interim measures preceded the negotiation, the twenty-day period to sue is suspended and then resumes. BOE-A-2025-76
- Art. 18.2 CE. Declares the home inviolable and forbids any entry or search without the consent of the person entitled or a court decision, save in the case of a crime caught in the act. BOE-A-1978-31229
- Arts. 1101, 1964.2 y 1968.2 CC. Requires whoever breaches his obligations to compensate the damage; personal actions with no special period are time-barred five years after performance can be demanded, and for continuing obligations to do or not to do the period starts each time they are breached; the action for fault under article 1902 is time-barred one year after the injured party learned of it. BOE-A-1889-4763
Each article checked against the consolidated text published in the BOE (the Spanish official gazette).
Frequently asked questions
Can the community go in with a locksmith if the neighbour will not open the door?
No. Article 18.2 of the Spanish Constitution only allows a home to be entered with the consent of the person entitled or a court decision, and forcing entry exposes whoever does it to a criminal complaint. If it is urgent, the route is to ask the court for entry as an interim measure before the claim, without prior negotiation and, where justified, without hearing the neighbour: the order is issued within five days (art. 733.2 of the Civil Procedure Act). Once security is lodged, it is carried out with the means used to enforce judgments, including a locksmith and police assistance (art. 738.1).
Who pays for breaking and restoring the neighbour's tiles or kitchen?
The community. Article 9.1(c) of the Horizontal Property Act gives the owner who puts up with the works the right to have the community make good the damage and loss: restoration with equivalent materials and, if he is left without a bathroom or kitchen for days, that loss too. What he cannot do is demand payment before opening up, or an upgrade at everyone's expense. And if, when refitting, he walled up the inspection hatch or boxed in the stack without telling the community, it can be argued that the extra cost of opening up is his.
I live below and the water is coming into my home. Can I take legal action myself without waiting for the community?
Yes. You can claim your loss from the community, which must keep the stack in repair, and from the owner who is blocking the repair, who is answerable to the other owners for the damage he causes (art. 9.1(g) of the Horizontal Property Act). If you rely on article 1902 of the Civil Code, you have one year from learning of the damage (art. 1968.2), and before suing you must attempt the prior negotiation, whose request interrupts that period. The Tribunal Supremo also accepts that an owner may act for the benefit of the community when it does not act and does not object.
Is an owners' meeting needed to force the neighbour?
For upkeep works, no: article 10.1(a) of the Horizontal Property Act makes them compulsory without a prior resolution, and the property manager orders urgent repairs, informing the president (art. 20.1(c)). To sue in the community's name, yes: the Tribunal Supremo requires, unless the by-laws say otherwise, a resolution of the meeting authorising the president. If it is urgent, the extraordinary meeting is called with as much notice as possible (art. 16.3), and the same resolution authorises both the interim measure and the claim.
It is to install the lift and it takes part of my storage room. Can they force me?
Yes, if the resolution was passed by the majority of owners and quotas in article 17.2 or the works are compulsory under article 10.1(b), with compensation and provided the occupation does not cost you habitability or functionality, which is the Tribunal Supremo's test. If the works make part of the building unusable for you, your express consent is needed (art. 17.4). To challenge the resolution you had three months, or one year if it breaches the law or the by-laws, counted from the meeting or, if you did not attend, from when you were notified (art. 18.3), and the challenge does not stop the works unless an interim measure is granted (art. 18.4).
This guide explains how the action works in general. It does not replace the study of your own case: deadlines depend on when things happened and on what you have done since.