Leaks or falling debris from your building's common parts: who pays
Last updated 2026-11-10 · Reviewed by Jaime Piñeira Pardo, registered with the ICAM bar, no. 138826
The short answer
You claim against the comunidad de propietarios (the owners' community), which is bound to keep the common parts in repair, and at the same time against its insurer, before the sección civil of the Tribunal de Instancia (the civil section of the first-instance court) where the building stands, after an attempt to negotiate. A tenant, a passer-by or the owner of a car has one year from learning of the damage; a flat owner has five according to many courts, but the prudent course is to count on one.
You live on the fourth floor of a 1978 building in Valencia, directly beneath the penthouse terrace, which the upstairs neighbour has for his exclusive use but which also serves as the roof. Since the rains of October last year, every time it rains heavily water comes through the ceiling of your living room and bedroom: the plaster has come away, the parquet in the hallway has lifted and the built-in wardrobe smells of mould. You reported it to the property manager by email in November and again in March. The loss adjuster from the community's insurer came and said that the water gets in through the terrace and that the policy pays “for the damage, but not for the cause”. The May owners' meeting postponed the repair until three quotes had been obtained, and now the property manager tells you that the terrace belongs to the penthouse neighbour and that you should claim against him; the neighbour replies that he cleans the drains and that the waterproofing is the community's business. Last week, on top of that, a piece of the cornice broke away and smashed the windscreen of your son's car, parked in front of the entrance. You want to know who to sue, how much time is left and what you must not do while it keeps raining.
The case, in five lines
- What is brought
- Against the community, an owner claims compensation for the damage caused by its failure to keep the common parts in repair (art. 10.1(a) of the Ley de Propiedad Horizontal, the Horizontal Property Act, and art. 1101 of the Código Civil, the Spanish Civil Code) together with an order to repair the cause. Someone who is not an owner (the tenant, the passer-by, the owner of the car) brings the action for non-contractual liability (art. 1902 of the Civil Code and, if part of the building breaks away, art. 1907). At the same time, a direct action against the community's insurer (art. 76 of the Ley de Contrato de Seguro, the Insurance Contracts Act). If the source is private, the claim goes against the neighbour (art. 9.1(b) of the Horizontal Property Act) or against whoever lives in the home the object fell from (art. 1910 of the Civil Code).
- Before which court
- The sección civil of the Tribunal de Instancia (the civil section of the first-instance court) for the place where the building stands: for an owner, because it is a horizontal property matter (art. 52.1.8 of the Ley de Enjuiciamiento Civil, the Civil Procedure Act); for a third party, because the community may be sued wherever it carries on its activity (art. 51.2 of the Civil Procedure Act), and where there are several defendants the claimant may choose any of the competent courts (art. 53.2). If an owner claims only money on the basis of the Horizontal Property Act, the juicio verbal (the shorter form of civil proceedings) applies whatever the amount (art. 250.1.15 of the Civil Procedure Act); if the owner also seeks an order to carry out the works, ordinary proceedings (art. 249.1.8). A third party's claim goes by amount: juicio verbal up to 15,000 euros and ordinary proceedings above that. Beforehand, an attempt to negotiate (art. 5 of Organic Act 1/2025). Appeal lies to the Audiencia Provincial (the provincial court of appeal), except in juicio verbal claims determined by amount of up to 3,000 euros (art. 455.1 of the Civil Procedure Act).
- Deadline
- It is a limitation period (prescripción), not an expiry period (caducidad). A third party (tenant, passer-by, owner of the car) has one year from learning of the damage (art. 1968.2 of the Spanish Civil Code); for personal injury, from medical discharge. An owner suing their own community: many Audiencias Provinciales (provincial courts of appeal) apply five years (art. 1964.2 of the Civil Code), because the action arises from the statutory duty of upkeep, but others apply one year, so the claim is made as if it were one. If water keeps coming in, the courts usually count from when the damage stops and its final extent is known. The direct action against the insurer gives no extra time. In Catalonia, three years for non-contractual liability. The period is interrupted by an out-of-court claim (art. 1973 of the Civil Code) and by a request to negotiate (art. 7 of Organic Act 1/2025).
- Who can bring it
- Claims may be brought by the owner of the damaged flat or premises; by the tenant or occupier, for their own loss (furniture, clothing, temporary accommodation); by a third party who is injured or whose car or property was damaged by falling debris; and by an insurer that has already paid the injured party, subrogated up to the amount it paid (art. 43 of the Insurance Contracts Act). The claim is brought against the community, represented by its president (art. 13.3 of the Horizontal Property Act), and against its insurer, and against the neighbour if the source lies in their flat or in the ordinary upkeep of their terrace. To collect later from each owner's personal assets in proportion to their share, that owner must have been sued and served with a demand for payment (art. 22 of the Horizontal Property Act).
- Financial risk
- The case is won or lost on the expert report establishing the source, which is paid for up front. If you sue the wrong party (the community when the source is private, or the other way round), dismissal comes with an order to pay costs (art. 394 of the Civil Procedure Act); if you win only in part, each side pays its own. Winning against your own community has a hidden cost: whatever it pays out of its funds is borne by all the owners according to their shares, you included; that is why the insurer is sued as well. In juicio verbal claims determined by amount of up to 3,000 euros there is no appeal: everything is decided at a single hearing.
First, where the water or the debris comes from: common or private
The question that decides the case is not who is to blame but where the damage comes from. Article 396 of the Spanish Civil Code lists the common parts of the building: the ground, the airspace, the foundations and the roofs; the floor slabs and load-bearing walls; the facades, including the external coverings of terraces, balconies and windows; the courtyards; and the pipes for drainage and for the supply of water, gas or electricity, all of them “up to the entry into the private space”. Up to that point the installation belongs to everyone; from there on it belongs to the owner of each flat, who must maintain it and is liable for damage caused by their carelessness (art. 9.1(b) of the Ley de Propiedad Horizontal, the Horizontal Property Act).
The most common dispute is a private-use terrace that doubles as the roof, such as a penthouse terrace. The terrace must not be confused with the common element that waterproofs the building: roofs and floor slabs are common elements (art. 396 of the Civil Code), even if only one neighbour uses them, and if water gets in because the bituminous membrane or the floor slab has worn out or broken, the repair and the damage are for the community; if it gets in because the neighbour does not clean the drains or broke the tiling, they are his, because article 9.1(a) requires every owner to make proper use of the common parts, including those for private use. The by-laws may allocate costs differently and must be read, but placing the upkeep of the terrace on its user is not the same as placing on him the waterproofing of the roof. In Catalonia, article 553-43 of the Código civil de Cataluña (the Civil Code of Catalonia) says so: the user looks after upkeep and maintenance; repairs due to construction or structural defects fall on the community, unless they result from misuse or poor upkeep.
The same goes for pipes. The main downpipe is common; a drain serving only one flat is usually treated as private until it joins the downpipe. And not every damp patch is a leak: the community's first line of defence will be that it is condensation caused by poor ventilation in your own flat, or water coming from a neighbour. That is why the expert does not merely put a figure on the damage but locates its source, with damp readings, watertightness tests, thermal imaging or a pipe inspection camera. Suing the wrong party means losing for lack of standing to be sued and paying the costs; if the expert finds causes attributable to both, both are sued and the court is asked to apportion liability.
The community must repair without waiting for the owners' meeting
Article 10.1(a) of the Horizontal Property Act makes compulsory, without a prior resolution of the owners' meeting, the works needed for the proper maintenance and upkeep of the building and its common installations, including in all cases those required for safety and habitability, whether imposed by the authorities or requested by an owner. Paragraph 2 adds that all the owners pay for them and that the meeting merely apportions the derrama (special levy) and decides how it is paid. The community cannot hide behind the lack of a resolution, a lack of money or the fact that it is still gathering quotes: necessary works are not voted on, they are paid for. Nor is it released because the roof has an original defect: it must repair it now and claim afterwards against the developer, builder and technicians, as we explain in our guide on construction defects.
What turns a leak into liability is knowledge. From the moment the community knows water is getting in, every rainfall that goes by without a repair, even a temporary one, is an omission on its part. Article 20(c) makes the property manager responsible for looking after the upkeep of the building, arranging urgent repairs and reporting them immediately to the president. An owners' meeting that puts off the roof for months while it rains inside someone's home is the textbook example of negligence, and the minutes recording it are the best evidence in the case. If the meeting votes not to repair, the resolution is challenged within the time limit (three months, or one year if it breaches the law or the by-laws, art. 18.3) together with a request for an order to carry out the works, as we explain in our guide on challenging resolutions.
The community answers for its debts with all its funds and the sums owed to it (art. 22): its bank accounts, the reserve fund and what owners in arrears owe it can all be attached. Only on a secondary basis, and after a demand for payment, can the creditor go after each owner for their share, and only those who were parties to the proceedings. And there is a cost few people explain: you are an owner too, and whatever the community pays out of its funds is borne by everyone according to their share, you included (art. 9.1(e)). That is why the claim is also brought against the insurer, whose payment does not come out of the neighbours' pockets.
If what falls is a piece of masonry: liability for ruina (disrepair)
When a piece of cornice, balcony or facade cladding falls onto a car or a person, the governing rule is article 1907 of the Spanish Civil Code: the owner of a building is liable for the damage resulting from the ruin of all or part of it if this occurs through a failure to carry out the necessary repairs. The facade, with the external coverings of terraces and balconies, is a common element, so that owner is the community. The courts read “ruina” broadly: nothing has to collapse; it is enough for a part of the building to break away.
Once it is proved that the piece came from the facade, the community will find it very hard to escape liability unless it shows that it inspected and maintained the facade, or that there was genuine force majeure: a storm of the kind that comes every winter is not, because a sound element does not break away in ordinary wind. Two distinctions should be kept clear. If what falls is a flowerpot, an awning or an air-conditioning unit, liability lies with whoever lives in the home it fell from (art. 1910 of the Civil Code), not with the community. And if the detachment is due to a construction defect, article 1909 points to the architect or the builder: the community will invoke it to shift the blame, which is why the expert has to say why the piece fell.
The person hit by the debris is not an owner of the building, so their time limit is that of non-contractual fault: one year from learning of the damage (art. 1968.2 of the Civil Code). For a car, that is almost always the day of the impact; for personal injury, the period starts with medical discharge and the assessment of lasting effects, not with the accident. Injuries are normally valued using the road traffic compensation scale (baremo), which the courts apply as a guideline. And if the community had fenced off or signposted the pavement and the pedestrian walked through anyway, compensation may be reduced for contributory fault.
How much time you have: one year, five, or as long as water keeps coming in
Someone who is not an owner in the building (the tenant, the passer-by, the owner of the car) claims through the non-contractual route of article 1902 of the Civil Code, with one year from learning of the damage (art. 1968.2). The tenant also has the contractual route against the landlord, who must carry out, without raising the rent, the repairs needed to keep the home habitable (art. 21 of the Ley de Arrendamientos Urbanos, the Urban Leases Act); but the tenant's furniture, clothing or the hotel they had to pay for are claimed from the community and its insurer, and within that one year.
For an owner suing their own community, the answer is not uniform. Many Audiencias Provinciales (provincial courts of appeal) take the view that the action arises from the statutory duty of upkeep in article 10 of the Horizontal Property Act, read with article 1101 of the Civil Code, and apply the general five-year period for personal actions (art. 1964.2 of the Civil Code); others treat it as non-contractual fault and apply one year. Article 1964.2 itself adds that, in continuing obligations to do something, the period starts each time they are breached: while the roof remains unrepaired, the action to demand the works stays alive. What is at stake is the compensation, and the firm's rule is simple: the claim is made as if there were only one year.
When water comes in with every rainfall, the damage is continuing, and the Tribunal Supremo (the Supreme Court) has held that for such damage the limitation period does not start to run until the final outcome is produced. With leaks, that usually means the clock starts when the cause is repaired and the full extent of the damage is known, not with the first damp patch. That is why the dangerous day is the day of the repair: from then on the period runs, and the community, having fixed the problem, is no longer in a hurry. The period is interrupted by an out-of-court claim that can be proved (art. 1973 of the Civil Code) and by the request to negotiate under article 7 of Organic Act 1/2025. The direct action against the insurer gives you no more time: count on the same period. In Catalonia, non-contractual liability becomes time-barred after three years (art. 121-21(d) of the Civil Code of Catalonia).
The community's insurer: what it can and cannot raise against you
Article 76 of the Ley de Contrato de Seguro (the Insurance Contracts Act) gives you a direct action against the community's liability insurer, so that you can require it to compensate you without going through the community. That action is immune to the defences the insurer may have against its policyholder: it cannot argue against you that the community notified the claim late. It may only raise your own exclusive fault and any personal defences it has against you. The community is obliged to tell you which insurance it has and what it covers; if it refuses, the court can order the policy to be produced as a preliminary measure (art. 256.1.5 of the Civil Procedure Act), with no need to negotiate first (art. 5.3 of Organic Act 1/2025).
What the insurer can dispute is what the contract covers: liability insurance covers the obligation to compensate for events provided for in the policy and within its limits (art. 73). Hence the phrase every injured party hears: “the insurance pays for the damage, but not for the cause”. It is true and it does not harm you, because repairing the roof is not the insurer's job but the community's, by law; what does not suit you is to accept payment for repainting the ceiling and treat the matter as closed while water keeps coming in. If the insurer fails to pay within three months of the incident, the court imposes on it, of its own motion, statutory interest increased by 50%, and no less than 20% a year once two years have passed (art. 20), running in your favour from the date of the incident unless it proves it did not know of it until your claim, or that it had good cause not to pay, such as genuine doubt about the source. That is why the claim is sent to the insurer from day one and the source is established early.
If you have home insurance, report the claim: it usually pays, through its own loss adjuster, for the repair of your home and then claims what it paid from the community or its insurer, because it is subrogated to your rights up to that amount (art. 43 of the Insurance Contracts Act). Whatever your insurance does not cover (the excess, rent you could not collect, temporary accommodation, furniture above the limit, the nuisance of living with damp for months) you still claim yourself, and if both of you claim against the party liable, what is recovered is shared in proportion to each one's interest. Be careful about signing an agreement with the community in which you waive everything: the same article 43 makes you liable for any harm you cause to your insurer's right of subrogation.
Before suing: negotiate with everyone, with the expert report on the table
A damages claim is a civil declaratory action, so article 5 of Organic Act 1/2025 requires a prior attempt at a negotiated solution, with the same subject matter in the negotiation as in the eventual claim. Direct negotiation between the parties or between their lawyers is enough. Since both the community and its insurer will be sued, the request is addressed to both, with the expert report and a figure: if you sue someone who was not invited to negotiate, they may argue that the requirement has not been met as regards them, and a claim without it is not admitted (art. 403.2 of the Civil Procedure Act).
A request that defines its subject matter interrupts the limitation period from the attempt to deliver it (art. 7.1); if within thirty calendar days no first meeting is held or no written reply is received, the period starts again and the way to court is open. There is one year to file the claim with the requirement met: if there was no reply, from the date the other side received the request; if there was a negotiation without agreement, from the date it ended (art. 7.3). A community that needs an owners' meeting to accept a settlement must call one, because the clock does not wait for it. And costs reward those who negotiate: they are not awarded in favour of a party that refused without good cause, and the party that asked to negotiate is exempt from them if the other side refused, unless there was abuse (art. 394 of the Civil Procedure Act).
Not everything has to wait for that negotiation. Interim measures before the claim and preliminary measures do not require it (art. 5.3), nor does a summary claim for the demolition of anything in a state of ruin that threatens to cause damage to the claimant (art. 5.2(f) of Organic Act 1/2025 and art. 250.1.6 of the Civil Procedure Act). If pieces of the facade are hanging over the street, the town council can also order the works, and that order makes them compulsory without a resolution of the owners' meeting (art. 10.1(a) of the Horizontal Property Act). The claim seeks an order against the community and its insurer, jointly and severally, to pay, and an order against the community to repair the element within a set time, with a warning that otherwise it will be done at its expense.
How we run the case, step by step
- 1
Document it today and give written notice
Dated photos and videos of each episode, damp readings and, if something falls, the piece itself kept safe. Notice to the community by a means that leaves a record, addressed to the president with a copy to the property manager, demanding urgent repair and the details of its insurance.
- 2
An expert before anyone repairs
Our expert locates the source (common or private; leak, condensation or rising damp) and values both the repair of the cause and the damage. If an insurer's loss adjuster visits, ours attends as well and we ask for a copy of the report.
- 3
Notify your own insurer and the community's
If you have home insurance, the claim is reported so that your home is repaired. The community's insurer is notified of the incident from the outset: for the purposes of its late payment surcharge, it will no longer be able to say it did not know.
- 4
Request to negotiate sent to the community and its insurer
With the expert report and a figure, by burofax (a certified, verifiable letter) or an equivalent means. It meets article 5 of Organic Act 1/2025, interrupts the limitation period and opens thirty days for a written reply.
- 5
Urgent measures if the damage continues
If water is still coming in or pieces are hanging loose, we demand an immediate temporary repair and, if it does not happen, we seek interim measures from the court, even before the claim. If the owners' meeting votes not to repair, we challenge the resolution in time.
- 6
Claim and enforcement
A claim against the community and its insurer, jointly and severally, for compensation, and against the community for the works within a set time. If they do not comply, the works are carried out at the community's expense and its accounts and the sums owed to it by owners in arrears are attached.
The evidence that decides the case
- The expert report that locates the source (roof, terrace, downpipe, facade or private installation) and rules out condensation: it decides whom you sue and whether you win.
- The dated notices to the community and the minutes of the meetings that discussed or postponed the repair: they prove since when it knew, and turn a leak into negligence.
- The report of the community insurer's loss adjuster and the building's technical inspection report: if they mention “leak through the roof” or flag the facade, they are the other side's own words against it.
- Dated photos, videos and damp readings for each episode: they prove the damage is continuing and fix when it stopped, which is when the limitation period starts to run.
- In a case of falling debris, the piece kept safe, photos of the gap in the facade, the report of the Policía Local (the local police) or of the fire brigade that made the facade safe, witnesses and, if there are injuries, the medical reports up to discharge.
- Invoices and quotes for the repair, temporary accommodation and furniture, and the lease that was lost: without them, the damage has no figure.
What closes the door
- Counting on five years as a tenant, passer-by or car owner: your period is one year. And, as an owner, relying on the five years: a court may apply the one-year period to you.
- Repairing, or letting the community repair, before an expert has documented the source: the evidence is lost and the insurer will say it could not be verified.
- Suing the penthouse neighbour, or only the community, without knowing whether the membrane or the drain failed: you lose for lack of standing to be sued and pay the costs.
- Signing the insurer's settlement “in full and final satisfaction” in exchange for repainting the ceiling while the cause remains unrepaired, or waiving everything in an agreement with the community that harms your own insurer's subrogation.
- Suing without having tried to negotiate with the community and its insurer, or letting more than a year pass since the negotiation ended: the claim is not admitted.
- Stopping paying community charges as a means of pressure: you lose your vote at the meeting and your standing to challenge its resolutions, and you expose yourself to a monitorio (fast-track payment procedure).
The law that applies
- Art. 396 CC. Lists the common parts of the building: ground, airspace, foundations and roofs, structural elements, facades including the external coverings of terraces, balconies and windows, courtyards, and the drainage and supply pipes, all of them up to the entry into the private space. BOE-A-1889-4763
- Arts. 9.1, 10 y 22 LPH. Each owner must make proper use of the common parts, including those for private use, and make good the damage their flat causes through carelessness; necessary upkeep, safety and habitability works are compulsory without a prior resolution and the meeting merely apportions the levy; the community answers with its funds and the sums owed to it and, secondarily, each owner who was a party, according to their share. BOE-A-1960-10906
- Arts. 1902, 1907, 1909 y 1910 CC. Whoever causes damage through fault must make it good; the owner of a building is liable for damage from its total or partial ruin if this occurs through a failure to carry out the necessary repairs, with recourse to the architect or builder where the damage results from a construction defect; whoever lives in a house is liable for things thrown or falling from it. BOE-A-1889-4763
- Arts. 1964, 1968 y 1973 CC. Personal actions with no special period become time-barred after five years, and in continuing obligations to do something the period starts each time they are breached; fault-based liability under article 1902 becomes time-barred one year after the injured party learned of it; an out-of-court claim and acknowledgement by the debtor interrupt the period. BOE-A-1889-4763
- Arts. 20, 43, 73 y 76 LCS. The injured party has a direct action against the liability insurer, immune to the insurer's defences against the policyholder, who must disclose the policy; an insurer that fails to pay in time owes statutory interest increased by 50%; whoever pays compensation is subrogated against the party liable up to the amount paid. BOE-A-1980-22501
- Arts. 52.1.8.º, 249.1.8.º, 250.1.15.º y 256.1.5.º LEC. In horizontal property matters the court for the place where the property lies has jurisdiction; actions under the Horizontal Property Act go through ordinary proceedings unless they are solely money claims, which go through juicio verbal whatever the amount; anyone who considers themselves harmed by an event covered by liability insurance may ask for the contract to be produced. BOE-A-2000-323
- Arts. 5 y 7 LO 1/2025. Requires a prior attempt at an appropriate dispute resolution method in civil matters, save, among others, for the summary demolition of a ruinous structure, interim measures before the claim and preliminary measures; a request defining its subject interrupts the limitation period, and the claim must be filed within the following year. BOE-A-2025-76
- Arts. 553-43 y 553-44 CCCat. In Catalonia, the community maintains the common parts in watertight and safe condition; whoever has exclusive use of a terrace or roof bears its upkeep and maintenance, and repairs due to construction or structural defects fall on the community, unless they result from misuse or poor upkeep. BOE-A-2006-11130
Each article checked against the consolidated text published in the BOE (the Spanish official gazette).
Frequently asked questions
The community says the terrace belongs to the penthouse neighbour and that I should claim against him. Is that right?
It depends on where the water gets in. Even if only he uses the terrace, the part that acts as the roof (the waterproofing and the floor slab) is a common element (art. 396 of the Civil Code), and the law does not confuse the two: if the bituminous membrane fails, the community pays; if the neighbour does not clean the drains or broke the tiling, he pays. The expert decides, and if both are to blame, both are sued.
The community's insurer says it will pay for the damage but not for repairing the roof. Can it do that?
Yes, and it does not harm you. Liability insurance covers the obligation to compensate within what the policy provides (art. 73 of the Insurance Contracts Act); repairing the cause is an obligation of the community that needs no resolution of the owners' meeting (art. 10.1(a) of the Horizontal Property Act). Collect for the damage without signing a full and final settlement, and demand the works from the community.
I rent my home and my furniture has been ruined. Do I claim against the landlord or the community?
Against both, for different things. Against the landlord, to make the repairs needed to keep the home habitable without raising the rent (art. 21 of the Urban Leases Act). Against the community and its insurer, for your furniture, your clothing or the hotel you paid for, through article 1902 of the Civil Code. For that you have one year from learning of the damage, not five.
A piece of the facade fell onto my car. How much time do I have?
One year from when you found out, which is normally the day of the impact (art. 1968.2 of the Civil Code). You claim against the community, which is liable for what breaks away from its facade through a lack of repairs (art. 1907), and against its insurer. If your comprehensive car insurance pays you, it will claim back what it paid; you claim the excess and everything else. Keep the piece, photograph the gap in the facade and ask for the report of the Policía Local (the local police) or of the fire brigade.
Can I stop paying my community charges until they fix the leak?
It is not in your interest. The charges cannot be offset against compensation that nobody has yet quantified, and an owner in arrears cannot vote at the meeting (art. 15.2 of the Horizontal Property Act), cannot challenge its resolutions without paying or depositing what is owed, and is exposed to a monitorio (fast-track payment procedure) and an attachment of assets. Effective pressure lies elsewhere: a written claim, a request to negotiate with a deadline and, if there is no reply, the lawsuit.
This guide explains how the action works in general. It does not replace the study of your own case: deadlines depend on when things happened and on what you have done since.