Your former property manager won't hand over records or funds
Last updated 2026-11-10 · Reviewed by Jaime Piñeira Pardo, registered with the ICAM bar, no. 138826
The short answer
The community brings the action arising from the mandate against the removed manager: hand over the minute book and records, render itemised accounts and repay the balance with interest and damages. It goes to the Tribunal de Instancia (the first-instance court) where the building stands, with a meeting resolution authorising the president and a prior attempt to negotiate. It is time-barred five years after removal; pre-action disclosure can be sought now.
You chair a community of 32 flats. At the extraordinary meeting in March the owners removed the property manager after years of minutes that arrived late and accounts nobody could follow, and appointed a new one. Eight months have gone by. The former manager has not handed over the minute book, the lift and insurance contracts or the list of owners in arrears; to emails he replies that he will do so “once two quarters of fees are paid”. Until you went to the bank with the minutes, he still had signing rights and online banking access. The statements show that the reserve fund account fell from 21,400 to 3,150 euros in one year, through transfers labelled “works provision” to an account belonging to no supplier. And a demand has just arrived from the Tax Agency (Hacienda) over withholding tax for the last quarter of 2025 that nobody filed.
The case, in five lines
- What is brought
- Personal action under the mandate against the removed manager (articles 1720 and 1724 of the Civil Code, read with articles 19.4 and 20 of the Horizontal Property Act): an order to hand over the minute book and records, to render itemised accounts of the management and to repay the balance with interest, plus damages (article 1101 of the Civil Code) and the direct action against his insurer (article 76 of the Insurance Contract Act). Where needed, pre-action disclosure first (article 256.1.2.º and 5.º of the Civil Procedure Act, LEC).
- Before which court
- The Tribunal de Instancia (the first-instance court, civil section) of the place where the accounts must be presented or, if that is not set, of the community's domicile or the place where the management was carried out, at the community's choice; in practice, where the building stands, which is also the venue for property-owners' community cases (article 52.1.2.º and 8.º LEC), under the ordinary procedure if accounts are sought. Pre-action disclosure goes to the court of the manager's domicile (article 257.1 LEC).
- Deadline
- Five-year limitation period (article 1964.2 of the Civil Code). For the demand to render accounts it runs from the day the manager left office; for the claim to the result of the accounts, from the date that result was acknowledged by agreement (article 1972). It is interrupted by a burofax claim (article 1973) and by a request to negotiate (article 7 of Organic Act 1/2025). In Catalonia, ten years from when the facts are known or could reasonably be known.
- Who can bring it
- The owners' community, represented by its president (article 13.3 of the Horizontal Property Act) with a prior meeting resolution authorising the claim. It is brought against the removed manager or secretary-manager, whether an individual or a company (article 13.6), and against his liability insurer. An owner who wants action takes the complaint to the meeting, which is the body that resolves complaints about the officers' conduct (article 14.a).
- Financial risk
- If the claim is dismissed outright, the community pays the costs, with lawyers' fees capped at one third of the amount at stake unless it acted recklessly (article 394.1 and 3 LEC); but if the manager refused to negotiate, the community is exempt unless there was abuse (article 394.4). Pre-action disclosure requires security, forfeited if no claim is filed within the following month without good reason (article 256.3). The community, not being a natural person, pays the fixed court fee (300 euros in ordinary proceedings). And winning is not collecting: if the manager is insolvent and the policy does not cover misappropriation, the judgment may stay on paper.
Nothing he holds is his, even if fees are owed to him
The community and its manager are bound by a mandate: he acts on its behalf and on its instructions (article 1709 of the Civil Code), and article 1720 requires him to account for his dealings and to pay over to the principal everything received under the mandate. The Horizontal Property Act fills in the content: the manager makes the collections and payments that are due and keeps the community's records available to the owners (article 20); the secretary keeps the minute books and retains for five years the notices, communications and proxies (article 19.4). And the reserve fund belongs, for all purposes, to the community (article 9.1.f).
The most common excuse is “I will hand it over when I am paid”. It does not hold up. Article 1730 only lets an agent retain as a pledge the things that are the object of the mandate until he is reimbursed his advances and compensated for the losses he suffered in carrying it out (articles 1728 and 1729); fees are not on that list, and the minute book and files are not the object of the assignment but the community's own register. The Dirección General de los Registros y del Notariado (the Directorate General of Registries and Notaries) put it bluntly: the manager owns none of the building's records and, once removed, must hand them all over, general and particular, whatever dispute there may be about his contract.
Nor may he keep the balance to pay himself: set-off requires debts that are due, liquidated and enforceable (article 1196), and disputed fees are none of those. Removal needs no cause, because the principal may revoke the mandate at will (article 1733) and the meeting may remove the manager before his year is up, at an extraordinary meeting (article 13.7 of the Horizontal Property Act); if his contract provided for notice, that is argued separately and gives him no right to keep anything. The same applies to a president who acted as secretary and manager (article 13.5): his duty to hand over is identical, although his fault is judged less strictly if he was unpaid (article 1726).
The first week: meeting resolution, bank and minute book
The president represents the community in and out of court (article 13.3 of the Horizontal Property Act), but the Tribunal Supremo (Supreme Court) has held that, to sue on its behalf, he needs a prior resolution of the meeting authorising him, unless the by-laws say otherwise. It is the first thing the former manager will raise. The resolution must be complete: removal or non-renewal, appointment of the successor, a demand for handover and for accounts, and authority for the president to negotiate, seek pre-action disclosure, sue the manager and his insurer, commission a forensic accountant and report a crime if there are signs of one.
That same day, the president goes to the bank with the certificate of the resolution and asks for three things: removal of the former manager's signing rights and online banking access, the record of authorised signatories, and statements for all the community's accounts for the last five years. The bank gives them to the community because it is the account holder; there is no need to ask the manager, and they are half the evidence. If the former manager processed the owners' data on the community's behalf, the processing contract required by article 28.3 of the General Data Protection Regulation must bind him, under point g), to return or delete them at the community's choice when the service ends: the demand letter asks for their return.
While the book is withheld, the minutes of the meeting that removes the manager are drawn up separately, signed by the president and the new secretary (article 19.3), and copied into the book once there is one. To have a new book certified, article 415 of the Mortgage Regulation (Reglamento Hipotecario) requires proof that the previous one was used up, save for loss or misplacement: in that case it is enough for the president or the secretary to state, on their own responsibility, in a notarial record or before the Registrador (the Land Registrar), that the owners were told of the disappearance or that the theft was reported. The new book records that no further minutes may be entered in the old one, even if it reappears. Recovering the old book is still necessary: it holds the resolutions that bind the community.
Five years from removal: when the clock starts and how to stop it
Claims against the manager are personal actions and become time-barred after five years (article 1964.2 of the Civil Code). Article 1972 sets the starting point: for the demand to render accounts, the day the person who had to render them left office; for the claim to the result of those accounts, the date that result was acknowledged by agreement. Count from the meeting that removed him or appointed his successor, which is the date he will rely on, not from the day the community discovered the hole.
The period is interrupted by an out-of-court claim (article 1973), which is why the burofax goes out as soon as there is a meeting resolution, not when the audit is finished. The request to negotiate under Organic Act 1/2025 also interrupts it from the recorded attempt to deliver it, although the count restarts if within thirty calendar days the first meeting is not held or no written reply is obtained (article 7.1). And there is a second clock nobody watches: defaulting owners' service charges become time-barred five years after each instalment falls due (article 1966.3.ª). If the former manager is withholding the list of debtors, the community may lose them while arguing with him, and that loss is claimed from him too.
Two variations change the calculation. If the manager was a company, the company is sued; if its directors caused the loss directly, the individual action against them is time-barred four years after it could have been brought (article 241 bis of the Capital Companies Act). And in Catalonia its own Civil Code applies: the secretary keeps the accounting records for at least five years (article 553-17), the minute books are kept for thirty years (article 553-28), the reserve fund sits in a separate account in the community's name (article 553-6.3), and claims become time-barred ten years from when the facts are known or could reasonably be known (articles 121-20 and 121-23), except defaulting owners' periodic service charges, which become time-barred after three years (article 121-21.a).
Pre-action disclosure: see the books before suing
If the former manager hands nothing over, or only part, the community can ask the court to make him produce it before the lawsuit. No prior attempt to negotiate is needed: article 5.3 of Organic Act 1/2025 expressly exempts pre-action disclosure, as it does interim measures sought before the claim. The competent court is the Tribunal de Instancia (the first-instance court) of the domicile of the person who must produce the material (article 257.1 LEC), which may not be where the building is; the claim itself, by contrast, will go to the place where the accounts must be presented.
Most courts read the list in article 256.1 LEC as closed, so the number matters. The application rests on point 2.º, which allows a request that the future defendant produce the thing in his possession to which the case will refer (the minute book, the files, the contracts whose handover will be sought), and on point 5.º for the liability insurance policy. Point 4.º, on the community's documents and accounts, is drafted for a co-owner against the community or against the co-owner holding them; against a professional from outside the building it is invoked together with 2.º, never alone. The application explains the case being prepared and offers security (article 256.2 and 3).
The court rules within five days and sets the security, which must be lodged within three (article 258); the person required has ten days to produce, and the community may attend with its forensic accountant (article 259). If he objects without grounds, he pays the costs of the incident (article 260.3). If he neither produces nor objects, the court may, if it considers it proportionate, order entry and search of the place where there are signs the documents are kept, deposit of the item or, where accounting records were sought, treat as true at trial the accounts the community presents (article 261). Then there is one month to file the claim: if it passes without good reason, the security is forfeited (article 256.3). That is why the invitation to negotiate is sent at the same time as the disclosure application.
The claim: handover, accounts, balance and interest in one case
Before suing, there must be an attempt to negotiate on the same subject matter the case will have (article 5.1 of Organic Act 1/2025), and if that attempt is not recorded the claim is declared inadmissible (article 403.2 LEC). Direct negotiation between lawyers counts, but a burofax that merely says “hand it over within five days” does not invite negotiation. The useful letter defines the subject (records, accounts, balance and damages), proposes a meeting, goes by burofax and to the email address the manager used with the community (article 7.1), and is also addressed to the insurer if it is to be sued. If thirty calendar days pass from receipt without the first meeting being held or without a written reply, the attempt has ended (article 10.4(a)), and the one-year period to sue runs from that same receipt (article 7.3).
The claim combines what many communities pursue in two lawsuits: handing over, with an inventory, the minute book, contracts, policies, vouchers and passwords; rendering itemised accounts of the management; and paying the withheld balance. If the statements allow it to be calculated, the figure is claimed in full or with bases that reduce it to an arithmetical operation, because the calculation cannot be left for enforcement (article 219 LEC). Interest is added on what he applied to his own use from the day he did so, and on the rest from the demand (article 1724 of the Civil Code), together with damages: tax surcharges, defaulters' debts that became time-barred, lost grants and the cost of rebuilding the books (article 1101).
It goes to the Tribunal de Instancia of the place where the accounts must be presented or, if that is not set, of the community's domicile or the place where the management was carried out (article 52.1.2.º LEC), which in practice is where the building stands, under the ordinary procedure, because the value of a demand for accounts cannot be calculated (article 249.2). His diligence is judged more strictly because he was paid (article 1726). His usual defence will be that the meeting approved his accounts every year: that approval covers what was shown, not what was hidden, and the forensic report proves precisely that the approved balances are not the bank's. And costs favour whoever negotiated: if the manager refused to negotiate, the community is exempt from costs even if it loses, unless there was abuse (article 394.4 LEC), and if he concedes the claim before filing his defence but after a formal, reasoned demand, bad faith is found and costs are still imposed on him (article 395.1).
If he does not pay: the insurer and the criminal route
The community has a direct action against the manager's liability insurer (article 76 of the Insurance Contract Act), and the insured is bound to disclose to it the existence and content of the insurance. That is why the policy is requested in the burofax and, if it does not arrive, through the pre-action disclosure of article 256.1.5.º LEC. Against the community, the insurer cannot raise the defences it has against its insured; if the loss is due to the insured's wilful misconduct, it pays and then recovers from him.
What the insurer does dispute is whether the event falls within the risk the policy describes. A professional liability policy is designed for management errors: the tax return that was not filed, the defaulter who was allowed to become time-barred, the grant lost for not applying in time. The disappearance of the balance may fall outside its scope. If he was a member of a professional association, ask also about its group policy and whether it includes a surety or fidelity cover. Reading the policies before suing decides whom to sue and what to claim from each.
When the money went to the manager himself or to accounts with no invoice behind them, there may be a crime: administración desleal (breach of trust in management) if he disposed of the funds by exceeding his powers, or apropiación indebida (misappropriation) if he made them his own or denies receiving them. The firm drafts the criminal complaint with the evidence already in order, but the sequence is decided carefully: if criminal proceedings are shown to be investigating facts on which the civil claim rests and their outcome may be decisive, the civil judge stays the case once only judgment remains (article 40.2 and 3 LEC). If the urgent thing is to recover the books and the balance, the civil route does not wait; and if there is a risk the money will vanish, a pre-emptive attachment can be sought before the claim, showing urgency and lodging security (articles 727, 728 and 730.2 LEC).
How we run the case, step by step
- 1
A meeting with a resolution that leaves no gaps
We draft the agenda and the resolution: removal or non-renewal, appointment of the successor, a demand for handover and accounts, and express authority for the president to negotiate, seek pre-action disclosure, sue the manager and his insurer and report a crime if there are signs of one.
- 2
Bank, passwords and certificates the same day
With the certificate of the resolution, the president removes the former manager's signing rights and access at the bank and requests five years of statements and the record of authorised signatories. The certificates and passwords he used to file the community's taxes are revoked.
- 3
Burofax with a demand and an invitation to negotiate
We send, by burofax and to the email he used, a letter with a closed inventory of what he must hand over, a deadline, a request for the policy and for the owners' data, and an invitation to negotiate with the subject defined. It puts him in default, interrupts limitation and opens the prior negotiation.
- 4
Pre-action disclosure if he hands over nothing or only part
We ask the Tribunal de Instancia of his domicile to order production of the book, the files and the policy (article 256.1.2.º and 5.º LEC), with security. We attend with the forensic accountant, and if he neither produces nor objects we seek entry and search or that our accounts be treated as true (article 261).
- 5
Forensic accounting on the statements
The expert cross-checks charges issued, collections, invoiced payments and the real balance, flags the unsupported transfers and quantifies the damages: surcharges, time-barred debts, lost grants and the cost of rebuilding the books. That is the figure claimed.
- 6
Combined claim and a decision on the criminal complaint
Within the month after disclosure, we sue the manager and his insurer: handover, accounts, balance with interest and damages, with a pre-emptive attachment if there is a risk the money will vanish. If there was misappropriation, the criminal complaint is filed weighing its effect on the civil case.
The evidence that decides the case
- The certificate of the meeting minutes with the removal, the successor's appointment and the president's authority: it proves standing and fixes the date from which time runs.
- Five years of bank statements and the record of authorised signatories, which the bank gives the community as account holder: they show every transfer, every cash withdrawal and who could sign.
- The burofax with certified content and proof of delivery, and the email sent to the address the manager used: they prove default, interruption of limitation and the attempt to negotiate the law requires.
- The contract or engagement letter and the invoices for his fees: they prove the mandate was paid, which tightens the standard for his fault, and define what was in his custody.
- The forensic accounting report that cross-checks charges issued, collections, supported payments and the bank balance: it turns suspicion into a figure the court can order him to pay.
- The Tax Agency demands, supplier claims and the list of defaulters with their due dates: they prove the damage caused by the withheld records and the poor management.
What closes the door
- Suing without a meeting resolution authorising the president. It is the first thing the manager will argue, and the case may be dismissed without the merits ever being heard.
- Leaving the former manager with signing rights or online banking access after the meeting. As long as he keeps access, he can go on moving the funds.
- Signing a receipt “in full agreement” with no inventory and no reservation to review the accounts. The manager will present it as approval of his management.
- Waiting for the audit to finish before claiming. The action to demand accounts is time-barred five years after removal, and waiting does not stop the clock: it is interrupted by an out-of-court claim, a request to negotiate, the lawsuit itself or an acknowledgement of the debt by the manager.
- Filing the claim without a documented attempt to negotiate, or with a burofax that only demands and does not invite negotiation. The claim is declared inadmissible (article 403.2 LEC).
- Seeking only a generic order to render accounts when the statements already allow the figure to be calculated. It forces a second lawsuit to collect, because the calculation cannot be left for enforcement (article 219 LEC).
The law that applies
- Art. 20 LPH. Gives the manager the duty to make the payments and collections that are due, to act where appropriate as secretary of the meeting and to keep the community's records available to the owners. BOE-A-1960-10906
- Art. 1720 CC. Requires every agent to account for his dealings and to pay over to the principal everything received under the mandate, even if what was received was not owed to the principal. BOE-A-1889-4763
- Art. 1964.2 CC. Personal actions with no special period become time-barred five years after performance of the obligation could be demanded. BOE-A-1889-4763
- Art. 1972 CC. Limitation for the action to demand accounts runs from the day those who had to render them left office, and for the action on their result, from when that result was acknowledged by agreement of the parties. BOE-A-1889-4763
- Art. 256 LEC. Allows a case to be prepared by asking the future defendant to produce the thing in his possession (1.2.º) or by seeking production of the liability insurance contract (1.5.º), with security forfeited if no claim follows within a month without sufficient reason. BOE-A-2000-323
- Art. 261 LEC. If the person required neither complies nor objects, it allows entry and search to seize the documents, production of the item to the applicant and its deposit, or treating as true the accounts and data the applicant presents. BOE-A-2000-323
- Art. 5 LO 1/2025. Requires, for a civil claim to be admitted, prior resort to an appropriate dispute resolution method on the same subject, and exempts pre-action disclosure and interim measures sought before the claim. BOE-A-2025-76
- Art. 76 LCS. Gives the injured party a direct action against the liability insurer, immune to the defences it has against the insured, with recovery against the insured where the loss is due to wilful misconduct, and obliges the insured to disclose the insurance and its content. BOE-A-1980-22501
Each article checked against the consolidated text published in the BOE (the Spanish official gazette).
Frequently asked questions
The manager says he will hand over nothing until we pay his fees. Can he do that?
No. Article 1730 of the Civil Code only lets an agent retain the things that are the object of the mandate until he is reimbursed his advances and compensated for losses suffered in carrying it out; fees are not included, and the records belong to the community. If he is owed money, let him claim it. Nor can he set it off against the balance while his claim is not liquidated and enforceable (article 1196).
How long do we have to claim against him?
Five years (article 1964.2 of the Civil Code). For the demand to render accounts they run from the day he left office; for the balance of accounts acknowledged by agreement, from that acknowledgement (article 1972). A burofax or a request to negotiate interrupts the period. In Catalonia it is ten years from when the facts are known or could reasonably be known.
Can we have a new minute book certified if he will not return the old one?
Yes, on conditions. Article 415 of the Mortgage Regulation allows a new book to be certified when the previous one is lost or misplaced, if the president or the secretary states, on their own responsibility, in a notarial record or before the Land Registrar, that the owners were told of the disappearance or that the theft was reported. The new book records that no more minutes may be entered in the old one. Even so, the old one should be recovered: it holds the resolutions that bind the community.
The one withholding everything is the former president, not a professional manager. Does that change anything?
Little. If he acted as secretary and manager (article 13.5 of the Horizontal Property Act), he has the same duties of custody, handover and accounting. His fault is judged less strictly if he was unpaid (article 1726 of the Civil Code), but the duty to hand over what he received is identical. And since he is an owner, the pre-action disclosure of article 256.1.4.º LEC can also be invoked: it is designed for a co-owner to ask the co-owner holding them for the community's documents and accounts; if the community itself applies, the request also rests on point 2.º, on the thing the future defendant holds.
What if the money cannot be found? Does his insurance pay?
It depends on the policy. The community has a direct action against the liability insurer (article 76 of the Insurance Contract Act), which cannot raise against it the defences it has against its insured and, in the case of wilful misconduct, pays and then recovers from him. But it will argue whether the event falls within the cover: professional policies cover management errors and may not cover the disappearance of the balance. The insured must disclose the insurance; if he stays silent, the court is asked to order its production (article 256.1.5.º LEC).
This guide explains how the action works in general. It does not replace the study of your own case: deadlines depend on when things happened and on what you have done since.